Skip to main content
. 2019 Jan 16;2019(1):CD011204. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD011204.pub2
Study Reason for exclusion
Acchiardo 1975 Wrong intervention: study of what solution to infuse for treatment of cramps
AIMS 2011 Wrong population: HDF rather than HD
Bachtiar 2005 Wrong intervention: tested low dialysate [Na+] versus BIS‐guided target weight adjustment on BP. The dialysate [Na+] in the latter group was not specified. The authors were emailed for clarification but never replied
Barre 1988 Wrong intervention: high dialysate [Na+] versus higher dialysate [Na+]
CARNIDIAL 2012 Wrong intervention: carnitine supplementation
Coli 2000 Wrong intervention: dialysate [Na+] with a co‐intervention of UF profiling
De Nicola 2000 Wrong intervention: neutral dialysate [Na+] versus high dialysate [Na+]
de Vries 1990 Wrong intervention: dialysate [Na+] with a co‐intervention of UF profiling
Ebrahimi 2017 Wrong intervention: dialysate [Na+] not < 138 mM
Ekart 2015 Wrong population: HDF rather than HD
Enia 1998 Wrong population: CAPD patients
Ficociello 2012 Wrong intervention: specific alignment of dialysate [Na+] to serum [Na+]
HEMATOL 2013 Wrong population: critically ill rather than maintenance HD patients
Henrich 1983 Wrong intervention: high sodium bicarbonate and acetate HD
Lambie 2005 Wrong intervention: on‐line conductivity monitoring; did not compare low dialysate [Na+] to medium or high dialysate [Na+]
Levin 1996 Wrong intervention: did not test low dialysate [Na+]
Macon 1995 Wrong intervention: slow HD versus dialysate [Na+] modelling
Mahiout 1987 Wrong intervention: high dialysate [Na+] versus higher dialysate [Na+]
Meira 2010 Wrong intervention: high dialysate [Na+] versus profiled dialysate [Na+] with an average dialysate [Na+] that was also high
Moret 2006 Wrong intervention: neutral dialysate [Na+] versus high dialysate [Na+]
NCT01015313 This study has been withdrawn prior to enrolment
NCT01168947 Wrong intervention: saline versus 5% dextrose as priming and rinsing fluids
NCT01766882 Wrong intervention: goal weight challenging versus dietary sodium restriction in the setting of a fixed dialysate [Na+] of 137 mM
Oliver 2001 Wrong population: effect of low dialysate [Na+] on patients with high or low baseline IDWG
Oliver 2001a Wrong intervention: dialysate [Na+] with a co‐intervention of UF profiling
Robberechts 2013 Wrong intervention: the authors did not define low dialysate [Na+], although the study meets the other criteria to be included in the review. The authors were emailed for clarification but never replied
Sandy 1996 Wrong population: critically ill rather than maintenance HD patients
Sang 1997 Wrong intervention: high dialysate [Na+] to higher dialysate [Na+]
Selby 2007 Wrong intervention: low dialysate [Na+] to lower dialysate [Na+]

BP ‐ blood pressure; CAPD ‐ continuous ambulatory peritoneal dialysis; HDF ‐ haemodiafiltration; HD ‐ haemodialysis; IDWG ‐ interdialytic weigh gain; UF ‐ ultrafiltration