Lee‐Feldstein 1993.
Methods | CBA study | |
Participants | Automobile workers n = 11,435 USA 1 company | |
Interventions | Intervention: HLPP; n = 11,104, after cluster adjustment n = 97 Control: non‐exposed colleagues; n = 331 | |
Outcomes | Rate of STS, average change in mean hearing threshold at 2, 3 and 4 kHz in the worst ear follow‐up average 5 years | |
Notes | Long‐term Comparability ‐ intervention/control: age: adjusted hearing: adjusted |
|
Risk of bias | ||
Bias | Authors' judgement | Support for judgement |
14. Blinding (subjects) | High risk | not blinded |
15. Blinding (outcome assessors) | High risk | not blinded |
16. Retrospective unplanned subgroup analyses | Low risk | no additional analyses |
17. Follow‐up | Low risk | similar |
18. Statistical tests | Unclear risk | not reported |
19. Compliance | Unclear risk | not reported |
20. Outcome measures | Low risk | audiometry quality reported |
21. Selection bias (population) | Low risk | same factory |
22. Selection bias (time) | Low risk | same period |
23. Randomization | High risk | not randomised |
24. Allocation concealment | Unclear risk | not randomised, not applicable |
25. Adjustment for confounding | Low risk | adjusted for age and hearing loss |
26. Incomplete outcome data | Unclear risk | not reported |