Skip to main content
. 2019 Jan 28;2019(1):CD011651. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD011651.pub2

8. Process evaluation studies ‐ summary of intervention characteristics.

  Named theoretical framework Aim Intervention type Control Intensity Included in QCA
Al‐Sheyab 2012a Developmental stages (not named) To assess feasibility in the Jordanian context of a peer‐led, school‐based asthma education programme Triple A. Children received education through interactive teaching and learning activities N/A 14 hours over 6 days Setting and participants; further modifiable design features; stakeholder involvement and engagement
Berg 2004 Social learning theory To evaluate effects of the Power Breathing programme and individual coaching sessions on asthma knowledge and functional health status Power Breathing. Children received education in a group session on asthma management N/A 2 weeks Stakeholder involvement and engagement
Bignall 2015 None To test the feasibility and preliminary efficacy of a school‐based RCT on breathing retraining for asthma outcomes and anxiety symptoms Single workshop for children. Children received information on relaxation/breathing techniques 30 minutes of standard asthma education 2 face‐to‐face visits 1 month apart None
Brasler 2006 None To provide adolescents with knowledge and skills to take control of their asthma; to enhance knowledge and skills of school staff, health professionals, and parents Power Breathing. Children received basic asthma education and addressed social/lifestyle concerns N/A 3× 90‐minute or 6× 45‐minute sessions None
Bruzzese 2004 Self‐regulation theory To help students weave asthma and management strategies into their self‐identity ASMA. Students were taught how to manage their asthma to prevent symptoms and reduced quality of life. Continued medical education was also offered to medical providers Usual care 3 workshops 2 or 3 weeks apart for 8 weeks Stakeholder involvement and engagement
Bruzzese 2011 Social cognitive theory To test the efficacy of ASMA ASMA; academic detailing. Students attended workshops to empower them to manage their asthma. Parents received training on how to support their child's need to manage his or her asthma Usual care 8‐week programme/3× 45‐minute sessions and individual coaching sessions once a week for 5 weeks Further modifiable design features
Bruzzese 2008 Social cognitive theory; cognitive‐behavioural therapy To test the feasibility and short‐term outcomes of asthma: it’s a family affair! OAS and ASMA; caregiver education. Intervention students received education about asthma, based on existing materials, from coping with asthma at home and at school; OAS and ASMA Usual care 6× 75‐minute group sessions once a week for 6 weeks; caregiver 5× 90‐minute sessions once a week Setting and participants; further modifiable design features; stakeholder involvement and engagement
Carpenter 2016 None To test whether a tailored inhaler technique video intervention could be feasibly implemented by school nurses; to improve the inhaler technique of children with asthma Multiple sessions for children. Children watched a tailored video and demonstrated their inhaler technique before and after N/A 6 weeks or less None
Cicutto 2013 Social cognitive theory To prepare and support children with asthma to be successful managers of their asthma, thereby reducing school absenteeism, interrupted activity, and health service use Roaring Adventures of Puff. Workshops included goal‐setting and self‐monitoring, trigger identification, control and avoidance, basic pathophysiology, medication use, symptom recognition, and the asthma action plan, using interactive techniques Usual care Unclear Setting and participants
Crane 2014 Educational theory of Jean Piaget To pilot a shorter, condensed OAS education programme as an alternative, yet still effective, delivery approach compared to the lengthier original programme OAS. Children received education from OAS Non‐equivalent intervention 10 weeks Setting and participants; further modifiable design features
Dore‐Stites 2007 None Unclear OAS; Quest for the Code. Children received a computer game, home activities, and caregiver information N/A 20 minutes a week for 8 to 9 weeks Further modifiable design features
Engelke 2013 Case management theory To identify the process of case management used by school nurses, and when they provide case management to students with asthma. The second aim was to identify the impact of case management on parent perception of how well the child manages illness; parent perception of how well the child keeps up with school work; quality of life and academic achievement of children Case management; nurse meetings; multiple sessions for children; multiple sessions for staff. Children received education and counselling, and parent/family education was delivered, as well as education and healthcare co‐ordination for teachers/staff N/A Unclear None
Gerald 2006 None To evaluate a comprehensive school‐based asthma management programme in an inner city, largely African American school system OAS. The intervention included 3 educational programmes and medical management for children, as well as education for school staff Usual care Unclear None
Henry 2004 Unclear To determine whether an asthma education programme in schools would have a direct impact on student knowledge and attitudes toward asthma and quality of life of students with asthma; an indirect impact on teacher knowledge and attitudes on asthma and on school policies about asthma; and a sustainable programme after resources were withdrawn Asthma education. A package about asthma was taught within the PD/H/PE (Personal Development, Health and Physical Education) strand of the school curriculum Usual care Unclear Setting and participants
Horner 2015 Bruhn’s theoretical model of asthma self‐management To test effects of 2 modes of delivering an asthma educational intervention on health outcomes and asthma management 7‐topic curriculum. The intervention was designed for children in rural areas and included asthma information In‐school asthma classes 16× 15‐minute sessions for 5 weeks None
Howell 2005 Learning theory and behaviour modification To examine whether it was feasible to implement an interactive computer game at school health centres. Second, to examine whether exposure to the game was effective in increasing asthma knowledge, reducing asthma symptoms, and reducing unnecessary healthcare use compared with no exposure to the game Quest for the Code. Computer game Usual care 4× 30‐minute sessions None
Jackson 2006 None To evaluate knowledge and attitude outcomes of an educational asthma programme for third grade children with and without asthma Single sessions for children. Children completed an educational programme. Teachers were also encouraged to attend N/A 3 classes per session for 11 sessions None
Joseph 2010 None To develop and evaluate a multi‐media, web‐based asthma management programme Puff City. A web‐based programme was delivered to children to focus on adherence, inhaler availability, and smoking cessation/reduction Generic asthma websites Unclear Further modifiable design features; stakeholder involvement and engagement
Joseph 2013 Behavioural theory To evaluate a school‐based RCT to evaluate Puff City Adapted version of the Puff City computer programme Generic asthma education 4× 15‐minute sessions None
Kintner 2012 Lifespan development perspective To evaluate the feasibility of the SHARP programme for students, their family, school personnel, and community partners SHARP; Community Coalition component N/A Once a week for 10 weeks plus a 3‐hour community component Setting and participants; further modifiable design features; stakeholder involvement and engagement
Kouba 2012 Orem’s self‐care deficit theory To determine the effectiveness of the ICAN programme for nutrition knowledge and dietary behaviours Single workshop for staff; multiple sessions for children; Quest for the Code; Fight Asthma Now; additional nurse meetings; combined education N/A 8 weeks None
Langenfeld 2010 None Unclear OAS; case management; stand‐alone respiratory therapy. Children received the OAS curriculum and case management asthma strategies developed with teachers N/A 6× 40‐minute sessions for 1 school year None
Lee 2011 The functional context approach To evaluate the effectiveness and feasibility of using undergraduate nursing students as facilitators to deliver an asthma management programme OAS. Children received the OAS curriculum N/A Unclear Further modifiable design features
Levy 2006 None To evaluate the effectiveness of a school‐based nurse case management approach to asthma in students with poor control OAS; monitoring of students; health status. Students received OAS education and weekly monitoring of their health status Usual care 1 school term None
Magzamen 2008 None To evaluate the implementation of Kickin’ Asthma Multiple sessions for children; Kickin’ Asthma. Educational sessions, similar to the OAS curriculum. Customised letters were also sent home to describe health needs and goals for each child N/A 3 months None
McCann 2006 None To assess whether a school‐based intervention would produce clinical and psychological benefits for children with asthma Education; role‐play. The intervention focused on describing the respiratory condition through a role‐play Respiratory education 45‐minute session None
Mickel 2016 None To provide Iggy education to more than 75% of children with asthma; To increase asthma knowledge; increase families’ awareness of asthma; and cultivate collaboration between school nurses and asthma providers Iggy and the Inhalers intervention. Children received an asthma education video, poster, comic book, sticker, and trading card programme N/A Unclear None
Mujuru 2011 None To demonstrate the feasibility of a school‐based asthma education programme for students and to evaluate parents’ perspectives on the intervention OAS. Children received the OAS curriculum N/A 40‐minute session once a week for 2 months None
Pike 2011 None To assess student asthma knowledge gain, teacher acceptance, and grade appropriateness after an intervention Multiple sessions for children; integrated into the curriculum. Teachers taught lessons with information about asthma Usual care 7 lesson plans Setting and participants
Richmond 2011 None To increase the number of current provider‐written asthma action plans submitted to the school nurse at the beginning of the school year Breathe Your Best. Students were encouraged to receive an asthma action plan from their doctor and to collect their prescriptions N/A Unclear None
Spencer 2000 None To evaluate the OAS programme for children OAS. Children received the OAS curriculum N/A 6× 40‐minute sessions None
Splett 2006 None To evaluate the effectiveness and sustainability of the Healthy Learners Asthma Initiative Children received training on asthma self‐management. Licensed nurses and healthcare assistants received coaching and reinforcement from asthma resource nurses Usual care Varied according to asthma severity and need None
Terpstra 2012 Social cognitive theory To test a version of an intervention with a caregiver newsletter vs no newsletter Multiple sessions for children; materials for parents. Children received skills training on how to use a peak flow meter. Parents received a newsletter about an important theme from the research Intervention or intervention with a newsletter 6‐week training Setting and participants; further modifiable design features

ASMA: Asthma Self‐Management for Adolescents.

ICAN: I Can Control Asthma and Nutrition Now.

N/A: not applicable.

OAS: Open Airways for Schools.

RCT: randomised controlled trial.

SHARP: Staying Healthy–Asthma Responsible & Prepared.

Triple A: Adolescent Asthma Action.