Skip to main content
. 2019 Jan 28;2019(1):CD011651. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD011651.pub2

20. Summary of QCA results based on intermediate solutions.

Model 1. Setting and participant features School health centre High school Parents direct intervention recipients Teachers direct intervention recipients School nurses/others direct intervention recipients   Successful intervention
Pathway 1 Present Present Present Absent   Yes
Pathway 2 Absent Present Absent   Yes
Pathway 3 Absent Absent Absent Absent   Yes
Pathway 4 Present Present Present Present   Yes
Model 2. Recruitment and retention processes Additional marketing materials Provision of incentives Provision of catch‐up sessions Provision of reminders     Successful intervention
    No solution found
Model 3. Curriculum, pedagogy, and intervention emphasis Focus on establishing alliances with care providers Focus on asthma symptom recognition and management Tailored content Emphasis on personal responsibility Interactive pedagogical style Diverse pedagogical style Successful intervention
    No solution found
Model 4. Modifiable intervention processes Theory driven Run in class time Run in students’ free time School nurse key role in delivery or teaching Personalised or individual 1‐to‐1 instruction   Successful intervention
Pathway 1 Present Absent Absent   Yes
Pathway 2 Present Present Absent   Yes
Model 5. Stakeholder engagement School asthma policy Child satisfaction Teachers engaged/ relationships developed Parents engaged/ relationships developed School nurses engaged/ relationships developed   Successful intervention
Pathway 1 Absent Present Absent   Yes
Pathway 2 Present Absent   Yes
Model 6. Consolidated model Theory driven Run in students’ free time Child satisfaction Parents engaged/ relationships developed High school   Successful intervention
Pathway 1 Present Present Present   Yes
Pathway 2 Present Present Present   Yes
Pathway 3 Present Absent Present   Yes
Pathway 4 Present Absent Present Present   Yes

Absent: absence of condition is essential in triggering success.

Present: presence of condition is essential in triggering success.

QCA: qualitative comparative analysis.

‐ (symbol): presence or absence of condition is not essential in triggering success.