Skip to main content
. 2019 Jan 31;14(1):e0211563. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0211563

Table 5. Magnitude of change in physical performance variables for substitutes from timing of pitch-entry to the end of match-play.

Variable 0–5 min (n = 33) 5–10 min (n = 32) 10–15 min (n = 30) 15–20 min (n = 26) 20–25 min (n = 19) 25–30 min (n = 11) 30–35 min (n = 7) 35–40 min (n = 4) Time effects Position effects Scoreline effects
TD Absolute (m) REF -71.76
(-102.23 to -41.31)b
-73.29
(-104.32 to -42.27)b
-66.61
(-98.96 to -34.26)b
-71.39
(-107.16 to -35.61)b
-91.22
(-134.72 to -47.70)b
-92.98
(-145.39 to -40.57)b
-84.91
(-151.78 to -18.04)a
-11.30
(-16.97 to -5.63)**
MID˃ATT**
MID˃DEF*
WI˃DR*
WI˃LO**
Relative (m∙min-1) REF -14.58
(-20.70 to -8.46)b
-14.40
(-20.64 to -8.17)b
-13.62
(-20.12 to -7.12)b
-14.46
(-21.65 to -7.28)b
-18.26
(-27.01 to -9.51)b
-18.64
(-29.17 to -8.11)b
-16.45
(-29.90 to -3.00)a
-2.28
(-3.14 to
-1.14)**
MID˃ATT**
MID˃DEF*
WI˃DR*
WI˃LO**
LSR Absolute (m) REF -23.31
(-47.66 to 1.04)
-23.20
(-48.02 to 1.62)
-23.14
(-49.05 to 3.10)
-35.58
(-64.25 to -6.93)a
-31.80
(-66.70 to 3.10)
-16.07
(-58.11 to 25.97)
-16.07
(-69.20 to 38.04)
n/a MID˃ATT* WI˃DR*
Relative (m∙min-1) REF -4.59
(-9.36 to 0.16)
-4.63
(-9.48 to 0.21)
-4.75
(-9.81 to 0.30)
-7.05
(-12.65 to -1.46)a
-6.14
(-12.95 to 0.67)
-3.06
(-11.26 to 5.14)
-2.44
(-12.92 to 8.04)
n/a MID˃ATT* WI˃DR*
MSR Absolute (m) REF -32.61
(-47.06 to -18.16)b
-27.30
(-41.99 to -12.59)b
-26.31
(-41.60 to -11.03)b
-21.05
(-37.87 to -4.21)a
-38.47
(-58.82 to -18.12)b
-49.65
(-74.12 to -25.18)b
-34.21
(-65.41 to -3.01)a
-4.37
(-7.01 to
-1.74)**
MID˃ATT*
MID˃DEF*
n/a
Relative (m∙min-1) REF -6.52
(-9.41 to -3.63)b
-5.45
(-8.40 to -2.52)b
-5.26
(-8.32 to -2.21)b
-4.21
(-7.58 to -0.84)a
-7.69
(-11.76 to -3.62) b
-9.93
(-14.82 to -5.04)b
-6.84
(-13.08 to -0.60)a
-4.37
(-7.01 to -1.74)**
MID˃ATT*
MID˃DEF**
n/a
HSR Absolute (m) REF -19.70
(-28.85 to -10.56)b
-23.23
(-32.55 to -13.91)b
-21.03
(-30.75 to -11.30)b
-14.30
(-25.06 to -3.55)a
-25.50
(-38.59 to -12.41)b
-29.20
(-44.97 to -13.42)b
-33.23
(-53.33 to -13.12)b
-3.38
(-5.10 to -1.65)**
MID˃DEF* n/a
Relative (m∙min-1) REF -3.94
(-5.77 to -2.11)b
-4.65
(-6.51 to -2.78)b
-4.21
(-6.15 to -2.26)b
-2.86
(-5.01 to -0.71)a
-5.10
(-7.72 to -2.48)b
-5.84
(-8.99 to -2.68)b
-6.65
(-10.66 to -2.62)b
-0.68
(-1.02 to -0.33)**
MID˃DEF* n/a
SPR Absolute (m) REF 3.83
(-1.38 to 9.04)
0.30
(-5.01 to 5.61)
3.63
(-1.91 to 9.17)
-1.04
(-7.17 to 5.08)
3.96
(-3.51 to 11.43)
-0.19
(-9.18 to 8.80)
-4.15
(-15.64 to 7.33)
n/a n/a n/a
Relative (m∙min-1) REF 0.77
(-0.28 to 1.81)
0.06
(-1.00 to 1.81)
0.73
(-0.38 to 1.83)
-0.21
(-1.43 to 1.02)
0.79
(-0.70 to 2.29)
-0.04
(-1.84 to 1.76)
-0.83
(-3.13 to 1.47)
n/a n/a n/a
PL Absolute (AU) REF -7.38
(-10.65 to -4.12)b
-8.49
(-11.83 to -5.16)b
-7.97
(-11.45 to -4.49)b
-7.60
(-11.45 to -3.74)b
-10.61
(-15.31 to -5.91)b
-12.56
(-18.23 to -6.89)b
-13.46
(-20.68 to -6.23)b
-1.67
(-2.29 to -1.06)**
n/a WI˃LO*
Relative (AU∙min-1) REF -1.50
(-2.16 to
-0.85)b
-1.68
(-2.35 to 1.01)b
-1.62
(-2.32 to -0.92)b
-1.55
(-2.33 to -0.78)b
-2.13
(-3.08 to -1.19)b
-2.53
(-3.66 to -1.39)b
-2.70
(-4.15 to -1.25)b
-0.34
(-0.46 to -0.21)**
n/a WI˃LO*
ACCdist High (m) REF -1.33
(-2.68 to 0.00)a
-2.48
(-3.85 to -1.11)b
-3.05
(-4.47 to -1.62)b
-0.61
(-2.19 to 0.96)
-1.54
(-3.46 to 0.37)
-4.03
(-6.34 to -1.73)b
-1.60
(-4.53 to 1.33)
-0.27
(-0.53 to -0.02)*
n/a WI˃DR*
WI˃LO**
Moderate (m) REF -3.22
(-5.03 to -1.41)b
-3.62
(-5.47 to -1.77)b
-3.59
(-5.52 to -1.67)b
-2.54
(-4.67 to -0.42)a
-3.80
(-6.37 to -1.22)a
-5.57
(-8.67 to -2.47)b
-4.74
(-8.69 to -0.80)a
-0.55
(-0.88 to -0.22)**
MID˃DEF* WI˃LO*
DECdist High (m) REF -1.24
(-2.29 to -0.18)a
-1.84
(-2.91 to -0.76)a
-0.93
(-2.05 to 0.19)
-0.30
(-1.54 to 0.94)
-1.75
(-3.26 to -0.24)a
-2.17
(-3.98 to -0.35)a
-2.40
(-4.72 to -0.08)a
n/a MID˃DEF** WI˃LO**
Moderate (m) REF -1.39
(-2.89 to 0.11)
-1.56
(-3.09 to -0.03)a
-0.93
(-2.53 to 0.66)
-0.53
(-2.30 to 1.24)
-1.40
(-3.57 to 0.76)
-2.47
(-5.35 to 0.14)
-2.02
(-5.35 to 1.31)
n/a MID˃DEF** WI˃DR*
WI˃LO**
#ACC High (IRR) REF 0.98
(0.74 to 1.29)
0.87
(0.65 to 1.16)
0.66
(0.47 to 0.92)a
1.11
(0.81 to 1.52)
0.74
(0.48 to 1.15)
1.01
(0.54 to 1.89)
0.76
(0.56 to 1.02)
n/a MID˂ATT* WI˃DR*
WI˃LO*
Moderate (IRR) REF 0.94
(0.80 to 1.10)
0.88
(0.74 to 1.04)
0.88
(0.74 to 1.05)
0.88
(0.73 to 1.06)
0.83
(0.66 to 1.06)
0.98
(0.74 to 1.30)
0.96
(0.67 to 1.39)
n/a n/a n/a
#DEC High (IRR) REF 0.70
(0.53 to 0.92)a
0.69
(0.52 to 0.92)a
0.66
(0.49 to 0.89)a
0.90
(0.67 to 1.22)
0.68
(0.45 to 1.03)
0.54
(0.31 to 0.93)a
0.57
(0.29 to 1.13)
n/a MID˃ATT*
MID˃DEF*
WI˃LO*
Moderate (IRR) REF 0.95
(0.75 to 1.19)
1.05
(0.84 to 1.31)
1.01
(0.80 to 1.29)
0.91
(0.69 to 1.19)
1.06
(0.78 to 1.45)
0.75
(0.48 to 1.15)
0.78
(0.46 to 1.36)
n/a n/a WI˃DR*
WI˃LO**

ACCdist: Acceleration distance, ATT = Attacker, AU: Arbitrary units, DECdist: Deceleration distance, DEF = Defender, DR: Scores level at the time of pitch-entry, HSR: High-speed running, LO: Team losing at the time of pitch-entry, LSR: Low-speed running, MID: Midfielder, MSR: Moderate-speed running, PL: Player Load, REF: Reference category for comparison, SPR: Sprinting, TD: Total Distance, WI: Team winning at the time of pitch-entry, #ACC: Number of accelerations, #DEC: Number of decelerations,

a different from 0–5 min at p≤0.05 level when ‘epoch’ modelled as categorical,

b different from 0–5 min at p≤0.001 level when ‘epoch’ modelled as categorical,

*: Significant effect at p≤0.05,

**: Significant effect at p≤0.001.

Data are reported as effect estimates (95% CI) except for #ACC and #DEC, which are incidence risk ratios (IRR).