Skip to main content
. 2019 Jan 18;13(1):e0007112. doi: 10.1371/journal.pntd.0007112

Table 1. Characteristics of included studies.

Study Country Age Sex ratio-Osteoarticular brucellosis (Male/Female) Sample size (brucellosis) Sample size (Osteoarticular brucellosis) Prevalence/Proportion Joints affected
Aktug-Demir et al., 2014 Turkey 18+ N/A 227 75 0.33 Sacroiliac, spine
Al-Eissa et al., 1990 Saudi Arabia 0–14 15/25 (37.5/62.5%) 102 40 0.39 N/A
Ariza et al., 1993 Spain 7–83 42/20 (67.7/32.2%) 530 62 0.12 Spine, hip, bursa
Aydoslu et al., 2006 Turkey 17–76 N/A 47 14 0.3 Sacroiliac, spine, peripheral arthritis
Benjamin et al., 1992 Saudi Arabia N/A N/A 157 57 0.36 Hip, knee
Benjamin and Khan, 1994 Saudi Arabia 0–12 N/A 190 70 0.37 Sacroiliac, spine, hip, knee, ankle, shoulder
Besharat et al., 2010 Iran   N/A 140 56 0.4 N/A
Bosilkovski et al., 2004a Macedonia 3–78 N/A 331 196 0.59 Sacroiliac, spine, hip, bursa, sternochondral, costochondral
Bosilkovski et al., 2004b Macedonia 4–69 18/15 (54.5/45.5%) 263 162 0.62 Hip
Bosilkovski et al., 2010 Macedonia 1–82 N/A 550 299 0.54 Peripheral arthritis, sacroilitis, spondylitis
Bosilkovski et al., 2013 Macedonia 0–14 N/A 317 133 0.42 Sacroiliac, hip, knees, ankle, bursa, shoulder, elbow, wrist, interphalangeal, sternoclavicular
Bukharie, 2009 Saudi Arabia 13–81 N/A 84 54 0.64 Spine
Bulut et al., 2011 Turkey 15–83 N/A 324 84 0.26 Sacroiliac, spine
Cirakli et al., 2015 Turkey 2–17 42/10 (80.8/19.2%) 52 11 0.21 Hip, knee
Colmenero et al., 1991 Spain 14–73 N/A 263 65 0.25 Sacroiliac, spine, ankle, olecranon bursa
Colmenero et al., 1992 Spain 14–82 N/A 593 58 0.1 Spine
Colmenero et al., 1996 Spain 14+ 2/- 530 2 0.004 Sacroiliac, spine
Colmenero et al., 2008 Spain >14 69/27 (72/28%) 918 96 0.11 Vertebral osteomyelitis
Dabbagh and Rasool 2009 Iraq <10 >60 N/A 80 45 0.56 Knee, spine, sacroiliac
Dahouk et al., 2005 Germany 4–72 14/16 62 11 0.37 Sacroiliac, sternoclavicular, spine, bursa
Demiroglu et al., 2007 Turkey 15–79 N/A 151 51 0.34 Spine, sacroiliac, tendon
Ebrahimpour et al., 2017 Iran 15–80 299/165 (64.4/35.6%) 1252 464 0.37 Sacroiliac, hip, knee, ankle, elbow, shoulder
Eini et al., 2012 Iran 9–88 N/A 230 118 0.51 Spine
Fanni et al., 2013 Iran 2–14 N/A 34 26 0.77 Hip, knee, elbow, wrist, ankle, sacroiliac
Fruchtman et al., 2015 Israel 0–19 N/A 252 92 0.37 N/A
Gonen et al., 2013 Turkey 15–88 N/A 201 50 0.25 Sacroiliac, spine
Gotuzzo et al., 1987 Peru N/A N/A 92 22 0.24 Sacroiliac, knee, ankle, spine
Guler et al., 2014 Turkey 3–82 N/A 370 178 0.48 Sacroiliac, spine, bursa
Gur et al., 2003 Turkey   N/A 283 195 0.69 Spine, sacroiliac
Hizel et al., 2007 Turkey 15–81 N/A 163 72 0.44 Spine, sacroiliac, paravertebral
Issa and Jamal, 1999 Jordan 3–14 N/A 68 38 0.56 N/A
Jia et al., 2017 China 3–75 N/A 590 137 0.23 Sacroiliac, knee, spine
Kazak et al., 2016 Turkey 15–85 N/A 164 87 0.53 Sacroiliac, hip, ankle, knee, spine
Khateeb et al., 1990 Kuwait 13–75 N/A 400 104 0.46 Sacroiliac, hip, knee, spine
Kokoglu et al., 2006 Turkey 15–69 67/71 (48.5/51.5%) 138 64 0.14 Sacroiliac, spine, peripheral arthritis
Kose et al., 2014 Turkey 14–83 N/A 72 10 0.31 Sacroiliac, spine
Kouba et al., 2013 Tunisia 19–74 23/9 (72/28%) 146 32 0.22 Spine
Kursun et al, 2013 Turkey N/A N/A 447 137 0.31 Spine
Lulu et al., 1988 Kuwait 10–60 N/A 400 105 0.26 Sacroiliac, spine, hip, knee, shoulder, ankle, elbow
Memish et al., 2000 Saudi Arabia 0–40 N/A 160 68 0.42 Sacroiliac, spine, hip, knee,ankle
Memut et al., 2012 Turkey 15–77 N/A 231 70 0.37 Sacroiliac, spine, bursa
Mugahi et al., 2014 Iran 11–80 N/A 81 8 0.099 N/A
Namiduru et al., 2003 Turkey 16–70 7/7/ (50/50%) 186 14 0.08 Spine
Okur et al., 2012 Turkey 2–16 N/A 147 20 0.14 N/A
Parlak et al., 2015 Turkey 1–16 N/A 496 55 0.11 Peripehral arthritis
Pourbagher et al., 2006 Turkey 2–77 N/A 251 114 0.45 Sacroiliac, spine, hip, bursa
Qehaja-Bucaj et al., 2015 Kosovo 2–74 N/A 124 55 0.44 Sacroiliac, spine, hip
Roushan et al., 2004 Iran 16–90 N/A 469 69 0.15 Sacroiliac, spine, ankle, knee, hip, wrist, sternoclavicular
Roushan et al., 2005 Iran 3–15 N/A 111 35 0.32 Sacroiliac, spine, ankle, knee, hip, wrist, shoulder
Santiago et al., 2011 Portugal N/A   90 44 0.49 N/A
Sasan et al., 2012 Iran 0–16 N/A 82 52 0.63 Knee and hip
Savas et al., 2007 Turkey 2–77 N/A 140 74 0.53 Sacroiliac, spine
Tasova et al., 1999 Turkey 15–75 51/36 (58.6/41.4%) 238 87 0.37 Sacroiliac, spine, knee, ankle, bursa
Ulug et al., 2011 Turkey 4–15 N/A 22 5 0.23 Sacroiliac, hip, spine, ankle, sternoclavicular
Zaks et al., 1995 Israel N/A N/A 90 40 0.41 Sacroiliac, spine, hip, knee, ankle, shoulder, elbow
Zamani et al., 2011 Iran 2–12 14/10 (58.3/41.7%) 96 24 0.25 Knee, hip, ankle, wrist elbow