Skip to main content
letter
. 2018 Aug 6;1:2. Originally published 2018 Apr 18. [Version 2] doi: 10.12688/aasopenres.12841.2

Table 2. Benchmarks identified in the Malawi framework, and approach to addressing them for the Uganda controlled human infection model for Schistosoma mansoni (CHI-S).

DSMB - data and safety monitoring board.

Malawi framework benchmarks Uganda CHI-S
1 Issue of national importance,
within the research agenda
graphic file with name aasopenres-1-13967-g0001.jpg  ✓   Over half of Uganda’s population estimated to be at risk from
schistosomiasis; vaccine development research supported by Vector
Control Division (VCD), Ministry of Health
2 Safety already demonstrated graphic file with name aasopenres-1-13967-g0001.jpg  ✓   Safety data from Leiden trials
 ✓   Risk assessments to Uganda to be developed
3 Model quality established by
published data
graphic file with name aasopenres-1-13967-g0001.jpg  ✓   Publication of Leiden trials expected in 2018
4 Strong scientific case, without
alternative approach
graphic file with name aasopenres-1-13967-g0001.jpg  ✓   Model has potential to fast-track selection of best vaccine candidates
accelerating development of safe, effective vaccines
 ✓   Available animal models may not determine correlates of protection and
vaccine efficacy in humans
 ✓   Understanding and data needed regarding differences between endemic
and non-endemic populations in response to candidate vaccines
5 Promotes capacity development
in country
graphic file with name aasopenres-1-13967-g0001.jpg  ✓   CHI-S preparatory activities already providing opportunities for learning
and debate for researchers, ethicists and regulators; continuing interaction
between researchers and regulators is planned
 ✓   Further developments to include relevant infrastructure development and
technical training of Ugandan researchers
6 Ethical acceptability including
issues of understanding consent
graphic file with name aasopenres-1-13967-g0001.jpg  ✓   Issues of understanding and voluntariness recognised and to be assured by
pilot work in target populations in preparation for CHI-S
7 Governance structure in place
(DSMB, sponsor)
graphic file with name aasopenres-1-13967-g0001.jpg  ✓   Protocol to be developed with due attention to these requirements