Table 4. HELP Program impact on cost savings.
Study | Sample size/site | Study Description | Methodology/Cost Savings Calculations |
---|---|---|---|
Bakker 2013 | 28 patients, 1 site | Before-after study with preintervention control and postintervention groups. HELP program was implemented; feasibility was examined and preliminary research data gathered. | Mean cumulative costs per patient three months after discharge were $11,979 for intervention group vs. $14,743 for control = $2,764 total savings per patient |
C. Chen 2017 | 179 patients, 1 site | Cluster-randomized controlled trial. Modified HELP program (3 key interventions) was implemented for abdominal surgery patients in Taiwan. | Cost savings calculated by applying cost savings from prior studies. For example, mHELP could have prevented delirium in approximately 674,576 surgical patients, resulting in a Medicare cost savings of approximately $10,000 per case or $6.7 billion for the year. By cutting 2 days from LOS, mHELP could have saved $1624 per hospital stay or $12.9 billion per year in Medicare costs for hospitalization. |
Caplan 2007 | 37 patients, 1 site | Two historical controlled studies of HELP implementation. | Cost savings calculated by applying rates from hospitals in Australia. $67,876 per year saved by decreasing length of stay through delirium prevention. $91,678 per year saved on hospital sitter costs for patients with hyperactive delirium. |
Leslie 2005 | 801 patients, 1 site | From controlled clinical trial, compared intervention and control groups for long-term nursing home costs when HELP was received during prior hospitalization. | HELP had significantly lower total nursing home costs, shorter length of stay and lower cost per survival day. Adjusted total costs were $50,881 per patient in HELP and $60,327 in control group = $9446 savings per patient (15.7%, p = 0.01). |
Leslie 2008 | 835 patients, 1 site | From controlled clinical trial, determined additional costs in control group for delirium (compared with intervention group) for 1-year health care costs associated with delirium. | Total cost estimates attributable to delirium was $16,303-$64,421 per patient; thus, the national burden of delirium was estimated at $38–152 billion each year (after adjusting for pertinent demographic and clinical characteristics) |
Rizzo 2001 | 852 patients, 1 site | From controlled clinical trial, compared intervention and control groups in true cost-effectiveness analysis. | Detailed formal cost-effectiveness analysis, accounting for all costs of intervention. Overall hospital cost savings of $1661–3779 per hospitalization. |
Rubin 2011 | 27,196 patients, 107 volunteers, 1 site | Historical controlled analysis done in a large quality improvement study. | Financial return of the program was estimated at > $7.3 million per year (from delirium prevention, shorter length of stay, and revenue generated from freeing up hospital beds). |
Rubin 2017 | 7628 patients, 1 site | Historical controlled analysis done in a large quality improvement study. | HELP lowers risk for 30-day hospital readmission (adjusted relative risk 0.83, 95% CI 0.73–0.94). This translates to 100 fewer readmissions due to HELP during the one year study period. A 2% reduction in the Medicare readmission rate would mean 40,000 fewer readmissions nationally per year, or cost savings of approximately $491 million per year. |
Zaubler 2013 | 595 patients, 1 site | Historical controlled analysis done in a quality improvement project. HELP adapted to a community hospital results in cost savings when variable costs were compared between patients and potential increased revenue calculated based on shorter lengths of stay for intervention patients. | Interventions resulted in $841,000 cost savings over 9 months for the hospital. |
Note: All cost figures in 2018 US Dollars