Skip to main content
. 2019 Jan 30;10:101. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2019.00101

Table 1.

Study characteristics.

Author (year) Diagnostic criteria Insomnia duration Assessment Comorbidity N insomnia N controls %Female insomnia % Female controls Age insomnia (M) Age controls (M) Pharmaco intake Caffeine intake Alcol intake Time of testing
Altena et al., 2008 RDC, Lichstein criteria >2.5 years Questionnaire Subclinical psychiatric symptoms 21 12 80.9 75 61 60 Excluded n/a n/a PM
Backhaus et al., 2006 DMS-IV 9.2 years Clinical interview Excluded 15 13 50 61.3 41.6 40.1 Excluded n/a n/a AM
Bonnet and Arand, 1995 SOL>45 or WASO>60 min, 4 nights per week for 1 year 8 years Questionnaire Excluded 10 10 n/a n/a 38.3 38.6 Excluded Excluded n/a Repeated testing
Cellini et al., 2014 RDC n/a Clinical interview, questionnaire Excluded 13 13 61.5 46.1 23.3 24.3 Excluded Excluded Excluded PM
Chen et al., 2016 ICSD-3 >6 months Questionnaire Excluded 21 20 71.4 65 41.8 38.1 n/a n/a n/a AM
Covassin et al., 2011 DSM-IV n/a Clinical interview, questionnaire Excluded 8 8 50 50 22.9 24.8 Excluded Excluded Excluded Repeated testing
Crenshaw and Edinger, 1999 DMS-III-R n/a Clinical interview Excluded 32 32 50 50 67.7 67.5 Excluded n/a n/a Repeated testing
Edinger et al., 2000 DMS-III-R >6 months Clinical interview Excluded 27 31 44.4 51.6 49.7 46.4 Excluded n/a n/a Repeated testing
Edinger et al., 2008 DSM-IV n/a Clinical interview Excluded 79 84 54.4 48.8 50 48.6 Excluded n/a n/a Repeated testing
Fang et al., 2008 DSM-IV n/a Questionnaire, actigraphy Excluded 18 21 66.7 66.7 34.1 27.8 n/a Excluded Excluded PM
Fortier-Brochu and Morin, 2014 DSM-IV, ICD-10 17.3 years Clinical interview, diary Excluded 25 16 56 50 44.4 42.8 Excluded Excluded Excluded AM
Guo et al., 2017 DSM-IV n/a Questionnaire Excluded 40 48 77.5 72.9 37.3 39.8 Excluded** n/a n/a n/a
Haimov et al., 2008 Lichstein criteria n/a Questionnaire, actigraphy Excluded 35 64 57.1 67.2 73.6 71.6 Excluded n/a n/a PM
Joo et al., 2013 ICSD-2 >1 year Clinical interview, diary, questionnaire Excluded 27 27 92.5 85 52.3 51.7 Excluded Excluded Excluded n/a
Khassawneh et al., 2018 DSM-5, ICSD-3 n/a Clinical interview, questionnaire, psg Excluded 35 54 71.4 70.4 40.6 31.5 Excluded n/a n/a Repeated testing
Liu et al., 2014 DSM-IV 6.4 years Clinical interview, questionnaire Excluded 36 26 58.3 61.5 42.9 40.5 Excluded Excluded Excluded n/a
Lovato et al., 2013 DSM-IV n/a Clinical interview, questionnaire Excluded 49 49 55.2 55.2 69.4 70 Excluded n/a n/a n/a
Noh et al., 2012 ICSD-2 7.6 years Clinical interview Excluded 20 20 90 90 50.8 50.4 Excluded Excluded Excluded n/a
Perrier et al., 2015 DSM-IV n/a Clinical interview, questionnaire Excluded 21 16 57.1 62.5 48.7 48.3 Excluded n/a n/a PM
Randazzo et al., 2000 DSM-IV n/a n/a Excluded 35 35 71.4 77.1 43.6 43.5 n/a n/a n/a n/a
Rosa and Bonnet, 2000 SOL>45 or WASO>60 min, 4 nights per week for 1 year 7.9 years Questionnaire, psg Excluded 121 56 38 32 35 36 Excluded Excluded n/a Repeated testing
Sagaspe et al., 2007 ICSD-2 >6 months Clinical interview, psg n/a 13 13 38.4 38.4 47.4 47.4 Excluded n/a n/a PM
Son et al., 2018 DSM-5 4.9 years Clinical interview, questionnaire Excluded 21 26 57.1 57.7 36.6 33.2 Excluded n/a n/a AM
Shekleton et al., 2014 RDC n/a Clinical interview, questionnaire Excluded 76 20 57.8 70 35.7 34.7 Excluded Excluded n/a Repeated testing
Siversten et al., 2013 DSM-IV n/a Questionnaire Excluded 30 91 n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a
Szelenberger and Niemcewicz, 2001 DSM-IV 8.2 years Questionnaire, actigraphy, psg Excluded 14 14 57.1 57.1 41.2 36.2 Excluded n/a n/a AM
Varkevisser et al., 2007 ICSD-2 n/a Clinical interview, diary n/a 39 20 58.9 50 40.9 42.6 n/a n/a n/a Repeated testing
Vignola et al., 2000 ICSD, DSM-IV n/a Clinical Interview, questionnaire, diary Excluded 20 20 10 10 61.7 63.3 Excluded benzodiazepine n/a n/a AM

AM, morning; DSM, diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders; ICD, international classification of diseases; ICSD, international classification of sleep disorders; n/a, not available; PM, afternoon/evening; PSG, polysomnography; RDC, research diagnostic criteria; SEI, sleep efficiency index; SOL, sleep onset latency; TST, total sleep time, WASO, wake after sleep onset. X = no group differences,

**

excluded if could impact cognitive function or reaction times.