Table 3. Soil physical properties at three different depths in the urban tree pits treated with bare soil (CK), cobblestones (CB), water permeable bricks (WPB), pine barks (PB), green waste compost (GWC) and turf grass (TG) two-years after mulching.
Depth | Treatment | Bulk density (g.cm-3) | Total porosity (%) | Macroporosity (%) | Microporosity (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
0–10 cm | CK | 1.47±0.13ab | 44.28±1.72b | 36.47±1.54bc | 7.81±0.38bc |
CB | 1.51±0.03a | 45.13±1.16b | 35.97±1.18bc | 9.16±0.30ab | |
WPB | 1.55±0.06a | 40.64±1.29c | 33.46±0.70c | 7.18±0.65c | |
PB | 1.39±0.03ab | 47.21±1.25ab | 37.84±2.37ab | 9.37±1.41ab | |
GWC | 1.34±0.04a | 49.96±1.22a | 39.67±1.63ab | 10.29±0.45a | |
TG | 1.39±0.07ab | 48.31±1.81a | 40.96±2.26a | 7.35±0.45c | |
10–20 cm | CK | 1.52±0.05a | 43.64±1.10bc | 35.41±1.14b | 8.23±0.34a |
CB | 1.48±0.03ab | 43.71±1.09bc | 36.77±1.52ab | 6.94±0.70a | |
WPB | 1.55±0.06a | 41.27±1.76c | 35.09±1.04b | 6.18±1.64a | |
PB | 1.42±0.03bc | 44.54±1.47bc | 37.69±2.22ab | 6.85±2.51a | |
GWC | 1.36±0.07c | 48.72±1.87a | 40.06±1.13a | 8.66±0.78a | |
TG | 1.42±0.05bc | 46.80±2.39ab | 37.86±2.45ab | 8.94±0.45a | |
20–40 cm | CK | 1.50±0.09a | 41.92±0.83a | 35.02±1.02a | 6.90±0.35a |
CB | 1.52±0.03a | 42.98±1.14a | 35.84±1.83a | 7.14±0.72a | |
WPB | 1.51±0.04a | 41.76±1.87a | 35.25±1.39a | 6.51±0.85a | |
PB | 1.54±0.07a | 42.76±1.15a | 35.24±1.13a | 7.52±0.60a | |
GWC | 1.55±0.07a | 41.69±1.51a | 35.18±1.24a | 6.51±0.48a | |
TG | 1.53±0.07a | 43.40±1.93a | 35.98±1.50a | 7.42±0.68a |
Values with different letters in the same column indicate significant differences between treatments (p<0.05, n = 3). Data are means ± standard deviation.