Skip to main content
. 2019 Feb 6;14(2):e0210777. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0210777

Table 3. Soil physical properties at three different depths in the urban tree pits treated with bare soil (CK), cobblestones (CB), water permeable bricks (WPB), pine barks (PB), green waste compost (GWC) and turf grass (TG) two-years after mulching.

Depth Treatment Bulk density (g.cm-3) Total porosity (%) Macroporosity (%) Microporosity (%)
0–10 cm CK 1.47±0.13ab 44.28±1.72b 36.47±1.54bc 7.81±0.38bc
CB 1.51±0.03a 45.13±1.16b 35.97±1.18bc 9.16±0.30ab
WPB 1.55±0.06a 40.64±1.29c 33.46±0.70c 7.18±0.65c
PB 1.39±0.03ab 47.21±1.25ab 37.84±2.37ab 9.37±1.41ab
GWC 1.34±0.04a 49.96±1.22a 39.67±1.63ab 10.29±0.45a
TG 1.39±0.07ab 48.31±1.81a 40.96±2.26a 7.35±0.45c
10–20 cm CK 1.52±0.05a 43.64±1.10bc 35.41±1.14b 8.23±0.34a
CB 1.48±0.03ab 43.71±1.09bc 36.77±1.52ab 6.94±0.70a
WPB 1.55±0.06a 41.27±1.76c 35.09±1.04b 6.18±1.64a
PB 1.42±0.03bc 44.54±1.47bc 37.69±2.22ab 6.85±2.51a
GWC 1.36±0.07c 48.72±1.87a 40.06±1.13a 8.66±0.78a
TG 1.42±0.05bc 46.80±2.39ab 37.86±2.45ab 8.94±0.45a
20–40 cm CK 1.50±0.09a 41.92±0.83a 35.02±1.02a 6.90±0.35a
CB 1.52±0.03a 42.98±1.14a 35.84±1.83a 7.14±0.72a
WPB 1.51±0.04a 41.76±1.87a 35.25±1.39a 6.51±0.85a
PB 1.54±0.07a 42.76±1.15a 35.24±1.13a 7.52±0.60a
GWC 1.55±0.07a 41.69±1.51a 35.18±1.24a 6.51±0.48a
TG 1.53±0.07a 43.40±1.93a 35.98±1.50a 7.42±0.68a

Values with different letters in the same column indicate significant differences between treatments (p<0.05, n = 3). Data are means ± standard deviation.