Table S1.
Study | Reason for exclusion |
---|---|
Mist et al, 20181 | Acupuncture vs education |
Ma et al, 20182 | Article in Chinese; not an RCT |
AM et al, 20173 | Dry needling vs cross tape |
Iannuccelli et al, 20174 | Not an RCT |
Zucker et al, 20175 | Secondary analysis of original article Harris et al, 200537 |
Li et al, 20166 | Article in Chinese; acupuncture + moxibustion vs Western medicine |
Disa et al, 20167 | Acupuncture vs electro-acupuncture vs moxibustion |
Yu et al, 20168 | Article in Chinese; acupuncture + herbal medicine vs Western medicine |
Weber et al, 20159 | No acupuncture therapy |
de Tommaso et al, 201410 | Cross-over study; only ten patients |
Casanueva et al, 201411 | Dry needling vs medical treatment |
Collazo et al, 201412 | Article in Spanish; acupuncture vs moxibustion vs scalp acupuncture |
Shao et al, 201313 | Article in Chinese; data unusable |
Collazo et al, 201314 | Article in Spanish; acupuncture vs scalp acupuncture |
Hadianfard et al, 201215 | Different treatment period. Acupuncture group received therapy for 2 weeks and control group received fluoxetine orally for 8 weeks |
Iannuccelli et al, 201216 | Not an RCT |
Collazo et al, 201217 | Article in Spanish; acupuncture vs traditional Chinese dietary therapy |
Itoh et al, 201018 | Five acupuncture treatments vs ten acupuncture treatments |
Jiang et al, 201019 | Article in Chinese; acupuncture + cupping + Western medicine vs acupuncture + cupping vs Western medicine |
Collazo et al, 201020 | Article in Spanish; not an RCT |
Li et al, 200921 | Article in Chinese; lower Dan-Tian acupuncture vs conventional acupuncture |
Zhao et al, 200922 | Article in Chinese; moxibustion + Western medicine vs Western medicine |
Targino et al, 200823 | Acupuncture + tricyclic antidepressants + exercise vs tricyclic antidepressants + exercise |
Harris et al, 200824 | Data unusable; only ten patients |
Sun, 200825 | Article in Chinese; not an RCT |
Li, 200726 | Article in Chinese; not an RCT |
Li et al, 200627 | Article in Chinese; acupuncture + cupping + Western medicine vs vs Western medicine |
Yao et al, 200628 | Article in Chinese; not an RCT; data unusable |
Harris et al, 200629 | Secondary analysis of original article Harris et al, 200537 |
Guo et al, 200530 | Data unusable |
Wang et al, 200431 | Article in Chinese; not an RCT |
Wang et al, 200232 | Article in Chinese; data unusable |
Liu et al, 200233 | Article in Chinese; did not meet ACR criteria |
Zhang et al, 200134 | Article in Chinese; data unusable |
Sandberg et al,199935 | Cross-over study; only ten patients |
Sprott et al, 199836 | Data unusable |
Abbreviations: ACR, American College of Rheumatology; RCT, randomized controlled trial.