Skip to main content
. 2019 Jan 30;12:527–542. doi: 10.2147/JPR.S186227

Table S1.

Reasons for excluded studies

Study Reason for exclusion
Mist et al, 20181 Acupuncture vs education
Ma et al, 20182 Article in Chinese; not an RCT
AM et al, 20173 Dry needling vs cross tape
Iannuccelli et al, 20174 Not an RCT
Zucker et al, 20175 Secondary analysis of original article Harris et al, 200537
Li et al, 20166 Article in Chinese; acupuncture + moxibustion vs Western medicine
Disa et al, 20167 Acupuncture vs electro-acupuncture vs moxibustion
Yu et al, 20168 Article in Chinese; acupuncture + herbal medicine vs Western medicine
Weber et al, 20159 No acupuncture therapy
de Tommaso et al, 201410 Cross-over study; only ten patients
Casanueva et al, 201411 Dry needling vs medical treatment
Collazo et al, 201412 Article in Spanish; acupuncture vs moxibustion vs scalp acupuncture
Shao et al, 201313 Article in Chinese; data unusable
Collazo et al, 201314 Article in Spanish; acupuncture vs scalp acupuncture
Hadianfard et al, 201215 Different treatment period. Acupuncture group received therapy for 2 weeks and control group received fluoxetine orally for 8 weeks
Iannuccelli et al, 201216 Not an RCT
Collazo et al, 201217 Article in Spanish; acupuncture vs traditional Chinese dietary therapy
Itoh et al, 201018 Five acupuncture treatments vs ten acupuncture treatments
Jiang et al, 201019 Article in Chinese; acupuncture + cupping + Western medicine vs acupuncture + cupping vs Western medicine
Collazo et al, 201020 Article in Spanish; not an RCT
Li et al, 200921 Article in Chinese; lower Dan-Tian acupuncture vs conventional acupuncture
Zhao et al, 200922 Article in Chinese; moxibustion + Western medicine vs Western medicine
Targino et al, 200823 Acupuncture + tricyclic antidepressants + exercise vs tricyclic antidepressants + exercise
Harris et al, 200824 Data unusable; only ten patients
Sun, 200825 Article in Chinese; not an RCT
Li, 200726 Article in Chinese; not an RCT
Li et al, 200627 Article in Chinese; acupuncture + cupping + Western medicine vs vs Western medicine
Yao et al, 200628 Article in Chinese; not an RCT; data unusable
Harris et al, 200629 Secondary analysis of original article Harris et al, 200537
Guo et al, 200530 Data unusable
Wang et al, 200431 Article in Chinese; not an RCT
Wang et al, 200232 Article in Chinese; data unusable
Liu et al, 200233 Article in Chinese; did not meet ACR criteria
Zhang et al, 200134 Article in Chinese; data unusable
Sandberg et al,199935 Cross-over study; only ten patients
Sprott et al, 199836 Data unusable

Abbreviations: ACR, American College of Rheumatology; RCT, randomized controlled trial.