Table 2. Between-method variability for measuring faecal calprotectin with respect to the extraction method used and stool consistency.
Hard Stool | Normal Stool | Liquid Stool | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
FC concentration mg/kg | P* | FC concentration, mg/kg | Mean bias,% | FC concentration, mg/kg | Mean bias,% | FC concentration, mg/kg | Mean bias,% | P† | |
Weighing method comparison, N = 52 | |||||||||
EliA™ Calprotectin | 104.0 (36.0 - 415.0) |
0.025 | 84.8 (22.0 - 257.5) |
87.9 (N = 8) |
74.0 (26.0 - 217.5) |
38.1 (N = 29) |
162.0 (58.5 - 1045.5) |
- 8.4 (N = 15) |
0.005 (1)/ (2)/ (3) |
Bühlmann fCAL® Turbo | 160.5 (59.5 - 611.0) |
491.5 (127.0 - 611.0) |
124.0 (57.8 - 373.5) |
152.0 (66.5 - 929.3) |
|||||
EliA Stool Extraction Kit vs Calex® Cap “N”, N = 77 | |||||||||
EliA™ Calprotectin | 91.0 (38.1 - 453.5) |
< 0.001 | 27.0 (19.3 - 61.3) |
89.2 (N = 11) |
77.0 (32.3 - 390.0) |
64.1 (N = 47) |
277.0 (88.8 - 924.3) |
8.1 (N = 19) |
< 0.001 (3)/ (1) (2) |
Bühlmann fCAL® Turbo | 190.5 (76.3 - 710.9) |
103.5 (41.1 - 594.1) |
249.0 (74.8 - 555.9) |
203.5 (95.8 - 999.1) |
|||||
FC - faecal calprotectin concentration is presented as median (interquartile range). *Wilcoxon test. Stool classes are presented according to Bristol stool scale (BSS): hard (BSS 1, 2), normal (BSS 3, 4, 5) and liquid (BSS 6, 7). †Kruskal-Wallis test with Conover post-hoc pairwise comparison. Mean bias - mean of calculated biases (Bias = [(FCfCAL Turbo – FCEliA) / ((FCfCAL Turbo+FCEliA)/2)] x 100). P < 0.05 was considered statistically significant. The allowable bias was set at 22.6%. (1)/ (2)/ (3) - respective biases differ significantly between 3 classes according to stool consistency; (3)/ (1) (2) - bias obtained for class 3 is significantly different from respective biases obtained for classes 1 and 2 according to stool consistency. |