Table 4. Sequencing studies in pediatric epilepsy.
Phenotype | Number | NGS test (number of
genes) |
Diagnostic rate | Reference |
---|---|---|---|---|
EE | 10 trios | WES | 66% | 25 |
EIEE | 6 trios | WGS | 67% | 26 |
EE (IS, LGS) | 356 trios | WES | 12% | 27 |
IS | 18 trio | WES | 28% | 28 |
EE, ES | 9 trios | WES | 77% | 29 |
PME | 84 single | WES | 31% | 30 |
IS | 10 trios | WES | 40% | 31 |
E
EE |
293
trio and singles |
WES | 38%
43% |
32 |
EE | 32 trios | WES | 50% | 33 |
EIEE | 14 trio | WGS | 100% | 34 |
EIEE | 14 trios | WES | 36% | 35 |
SEI | 114 | WES | 56% | 4 |
EIEE | 733 | WES | 42% | 36 |
DRE (abstract) | 74 | WES | 17.3% | 37 |
141 | E Panel | 32.6% | 37 | |
58 | Targeted WES | 44.8% | 37 | |
Focal | 40 single | Targeted WES (64) | 12.50% | 38 |
Many | 19 | E Panel (67) | 47% | 39 |
Many | 339 | E Panel (110) | 18% | 40 |
E | 87 | E Panel (1/2 - 83, 1/2 - 106) | 19.50% | 41 |
EE | 105 | EE Panel (71 genes) | 28.50% | 42 |
EIEE | 733 | E Panel (2742 genes) | 26.70% | 36 |
This table lists the diagnostic yield in studies using whole genome sequencing (WGS), whole exome sequencing (WES) +/- gene panels, and epilepsy gene panels. It gives the number of probands and the studies using trios (sequencing the proband, mother and father). The diagnostic rate refers to the percentage of patients sequenced who had pathogenic mutations in genes known to cause epilepsy. The studies were done at different times (early sequencing did not include some of the genes we now know cause epilepsy in children) and their definition of pathogenicity varies. Only one of the studies—Howell et al. 4—can be called a population study and it was in only a subset of infants with intractable epilepsy. In general, infants with severe generalized epilepsy or epilepsy syndromes have the highest diagnostic yield with gene sequencing. DRE, drug-resistant epilepsy; E, epilepsy (included adults and children); E Panel, epilepsy gene panel; EE, epileptic encephalopathy; EIEE, early infant epileptic encephalopathy; ES, epilepsy syndromes; IS, infantile spasms; LGS, Lennox-Gastaut syndrome; PME, progressive myoclonic epilepsy; SEI, severe epilepsies of infancy.