Table 1.
Study author and date | Country | Underlying theory | KT intervention typea | KT strategies | Participants | Personnel | Reported contextual factors |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Bennett et al. 2012 [103] | Multinational – Ghana, South Africa, Uganda | NR | Integrated efforts | Research reports and publications (indirect) Verbal briefings Policy briefs Conducting policy-relevant research and analysis Providing policy advice and technical assistance in policy formulation and evaluation Conducting policy dialogues at national level |
Policy-makers, donors, NGOs | Members of research institutes | NR |
Delany-Moretlwe et al. 2011 [104] | South Africa | NR | Exchange efforts | Building credibility through linkages – community advisory boards, community consultation workshop, monthly meetings Multiple means of communication – drama, music, radio and community eventsSMSFace-to-face meetings, telephonically, email (especially with policy-makers) Interdisciplinary workshops |
Researchers | NR | Disease burden, health system organisation, socio-political context of South Africa |
Guieu et al. 2016 [72] | Multinational – Kenya, Mozambique, South Africa, Burkina Faso, Malawi | NR | Exchange efforts | A ‘work package’ of translation activities, including strong involvement of stakeholders through inviting policy-makers to open meetings, key-informant interviews with policy-makers, workshops with policy-makers, fora for policy-maker feedback on research projects, policy advisory boards at each site, stakeholder workshops, policy recommendations in formats adapted to policy-maker needs | Researchers | NR | Importance of context noted, but not described,LMIC settings – resource constrained |
Hennink and Stephenson 2005 [105] | Multinational – Malawi, Tanzania | Models of research utilisation –rational, incremental and political models | Push efforts | Workshops Research report distributed Academic channels (journals, conference presentations) |
Health researchers, policy-makers and practitioners | NR | NR |
aAccording to Lavis et al. [56] push–pull–integrated–exchange model
NR not reported