Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2019 Aug 1.
Published in final edited form as: Addit Manuf. 2018 Jul 2;22:758–774. doi: 10.1016/j.addma.2018.06.024

Table 1:

Selected thermomechanical modeling literature, the authors’ overall strategy, and major outcomes.

Process Ref Material Energy Source Element Scheme Analysis Major Outcomes
DED Powder Feed [70] Ti6Al4V Ellipsoidal Hybrid 3D-Uncoupled, Pan Computing Incorporating forced convection boundary conditions in the model improves temperature and corresponding residual stress estimates.
[64] Ti6Al4V Ellipsoidal Quiet 3D-Coupled, Not Listed When printing on cantilevered plate for model verification, plate will tend to bend upwards.
[57] Inconel 718 + Ti6Al4V Gaussian Not Specified 3D-Uncoupled, ABAQUS For printing tall structures, reducing the layer thickness can increase distortion, while simultaneously decreasing residual stresses.
DED Wire Feed [76,77] Mild Steel Wire Gaussian Inactive 3D-Coupled, ABAQUS Residual stress across a line of deposit is uniform with low affect from previous layers’ stress profile.
[123] Steel Wire Ellipsoidal Quiet 3D-Coupled, MSC-Marc Final deposition path can have significant effect on the final residual stresses
[68] Inconel 718 Wire Uniform Source Inactive 3D-Coupled Using a large-strain plasticity model can result in higher accuracy, but also increases computational cost significantly.
PDF EBM [81] Ti6Al4V Gaussian None-Single Scan 3D-Coupled, ABAQUS Increase in bed preheat temperature as high as 50°C can reduce residual stresses by ~20%.
[124] Rene 80 (Ni-based superalloy) Gaussian None-Single Scan 3D-Coupled, SYSWELD Yield stresses were easily achieved after heat source passing.
[84] Inconel 718 Effective (Temp-Driven) Inactive 3D-Uncoupled, ABAQUS Preheating substrate prior to printing will reduce the magnitude of the residual stresses developed.
PBF SLM [65] AlSi10Mg Gaussian Hybrid 3D-Uncoupled, ABAQUS Relatively long laser exposure time (slower scan speeds) will tend to induce a much larger residual stress field.
[73] Stainless Steel 316 Gaussian Inactive 3D-Indirectly Coupled-FE ANSYS Residual stress calculation is reduced at high temperature when temperature-dependent thermophysical properties are accounted for.
[82] Ti6Al4V Gaussian Inactive 3D-Coupled, MSC-Marc No significant variation in residual stresses among different “square pattern” scan strategies, but significant variation in directional stresses.
[125] Inconel 718 Double Ellipsoidal Quiet Thermal FE-Only Pan Computing Assuming powder layer is insulator can significantly overpredict temperatures in component.
[62] Inconel 718 Ellipsoidal Hybrid 3D-Weakly Coupled Pan Computing Rotating scan patterns can homogenize residual stress fields.
[126] Fe-based Gaussian Inactive 3D-Coupled ABAQUS Equivalent heat source method used from single-layer simulated temperature field, reduced computational cost and maintained accuracy.
[71] Inconel 718 Gaussian Quiet 3-D Coupled, ABAQUS Rotating 45° scan patterns produce the lowest planar stresses and deformation when compared with other scanning strategies