Table 5. Perioperative and postoperative music therapy*.
Year | Intervention | N | Patients | Surgery | Type/quality | Results |
Symptom: Anxiety, stress, and sleep disturbances | ||||||
2013 (e18) |
Perioperative: music | 955 | Adults | Cardiac surgery/ intervention |
SR, Q high | Stress reduction: WMD = −1.26 (95% CI: [−2.30; −0.22], p = 0.02); anxiety: SMD = −0.70 (95% CI: [−1.17, −0.22], p <0.01); quality of sleep: smd = 0.91 (95% ci: [0.03; 1.79], p = 0.04) |
2013 (e19) |
Preoperative: music | 2051 | Adults | Mixed | SR, Q high | Anxiety: −5.72 pts (95% CI: [−7.27; −4.17], p <0.01 |
2015 (e66) |
Music vs other procedure or standard |
781 | Women | Gynecologic | SR, Q moderate | One study each showed a significant reduction of anxiety or fatigue, respectively |
2015 (e29) |
Postoperative: music | 630 | Children/ youth up to 18 years old |
Orthopedic, cardiac, and ambulatory |
SR, Q high | Anxiety: SMD = −0.34 (95% CI: [−0.66; −0.01]) Stress: SMD = −0.50 (95% CI: [−0.84; −0.16]) |
2015 (e4) |
Music vs midazolame | 123 | Children up to 7 years |
Ambulatory surgery | SR, Q high | Significantly better anxiety reduction with midazolame than with music therapy (p = 0.02) |
Symptom: Pain | ||||||
2015 (e66) |
Music vs other procedure or standard |
781 | Women | Gynecologic | SR, Q moderate | Significant reduction of pain (in five of seven studies) and of need for anesthesia (in one study) |
2015 (e29) |
Postoperative: music | 630 | Children/youth up to 18 years old |
Mixed | SR, Q high | Pain: SMD = −1.07 (95% CI: [−2.08; −0.07]) |
* The complete table is available in the eMethods
CI, confidence interval; N, sample size; pts, points; Q, quality determined by AMSTAR score; SMD, standardized mean difference; SR, systematic review; WMD, weighted mean difference