Photoactivatable fluorescent protein (e.g. PAmCherry) |
-
•
Genetically encoded fluorophore (no additional labelling required, labelling specificity guaranteed)
-
•
Independently controlled photoactivation with 405 nm excitation
-
•
Very low background noise (background can be bleached before photoactivation)
-
•
Cells can be imaged during continuous growth
-
•
Protein synthesis during cell growth replenishes fluorescence
-
•
Established and well-characterised labels
|
-
•
Low brightness limits spatial and temporal resolution
-
•
Observation time per molecule is limited by rapid photobleaching
-
•
Irreversible bleaching prohibits repeated measurements of the same molecules
-
•
Limited spectral range
-
•
Phototoxicity of 405 nm illumination for photoactivation
-
•
Multi-colour tracking is limited because most PA-FPs are activated by near-UV light
-
•
Quantitative localization analysis complicated by incomplete photoactivation and long maturation times
-
•
Aggregation artifacts have been reported
|
Protein tag labelled with synthetic fluorophore (e.g. Halo-TMR) |
-
•
Superior brightness provides enhanced localization precision and temporal resolution
-
•
Reduced photobleaching increases observation time per molecule
-
•
Available dyes span visible to far-red spectrum
-
•
Compatible with conventional fluorescence imaging
-
•
Multi-colour tracking possible using orthogonal labelling of Halo, SNAP, and CLIP tags with different dyes
-
•
Reversible blinking allows repeated measurements of the same molecules
-
•
Ability to perform sequential labelling (e.g. before and after a cell perturbation)
|
-
•
Additional labelling step (laborious, may interfere with other cell treatments, time-course experiments, etc)
-
•
Removal of unbound dye requires extensive cell washing and centrifugation
-
•
Labelled protein is diluted with each cell division, causing loss of signal during prolonged time-lapse imaging
-
•
Pre-bleaching step required before single-molecule imaging
-
•
Limited control over photoswitching kinetics
-
•
Reversible blinking produces apparent clustering artifacts
-
•
Quantitative localization analysis complicated by reversible blinking, unknown labelling efficiency, and dilution of labelled proteins during cell growth
-
•
Not all Halo tag dyes are cell permeable
-
•
Not all fluorescent Halo ligands are commercially available or can be expensive
|