Skip to main content
. 2019 Jan 22;2019(1):CD009363. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD009363.pub3

1. Treatment interventions of included studies.

Study ID No. centres No. participants (assessed/assigned) Surgical fixation Conservative treatment
Ahrens 2017 20 204/301 (67.8%) Plate fixation: LCP (precontoured titanium plate) Simple sling
Chen 2011 11 60/60 (100%) Intramedullary fixation: TEN Simple sling
COTS 2007 8 111/132 (84.1%) Plate fixation: limited DCP/3.5 mm reconstruction plates/pre‐contoured plates/other plates Simple sling
Figueiredo 2008 1 40/50 (80%) Plate fixation: 3.5 mm DCP plate fixation Simple sling
Judd 2009 1 57/57 (100%) Intramedullary fixation: modified Hagie pin Simple sling
Koch 2008 1 68/68 (100%) Intramedullary fixation: 2 mm pin Figure‐of‐eight bandage
Melean 2015 1 76/76 (100%) Plate fixation: 3.5 mm LCP/LCP reconstruction plates Simple sling
Mirzatolooei 2011 1 50/60 (83.3%) Plate fixation: 3.5 mm reconstruction plates Simple sling
Naveen 2017 1 60/60 (100%) Plate fixation: 3.5 mm DCP plate fixation Figure‐of‐eight bandage
Robinson 2013a 3 178/200 (89%) Plate fixation: LCP (precontoured titanium plate) Simple sling
Smekal 2009 1 60/68 (88.2%) Intramedullary fixation: TEN Simple sling
Tamaoki 2017 2 98/117 (83.8%) Plate fixation: 3.5 mm reconstruction plates Figure‐of‐eight bandage
Virtanen 2012a 1 51/60 (85%) Plate fixation: 3.5 mm reconstruction plates Simple sling
Woltz 2017a 16 154/160 (96.2%) Plate fixation: most operatively treated participants (80%) were treated with a precontoured clavicular plate Simple sling

DCP: dynamic compression plates; LCP: locking compression plate; TEN: titanium elastic nail