Skip to main content
. 2019 Feb 8;10:168. doi: 10.3389/fimmu.2019.00168

Table 1.

Comparison between CAR T-cells and T-cell recruiting bi-specific antibodies.

CAR T-Cells Bi-specific antibodies
Mechanism of action
  • - Direct cancer antigen recognition

  • - Non MHC-restricted

  • - Does not require pre-existing T cell infiltration, independent of receiver T cell characteristics

  • - Recruitment of immune effector T cells by their CD3 with another antigen expressed on the tumor cell

  • - Non MHC-restricted

  • - May be more dependent on quantity/quality of patients' T cells

Administration
  • - Single administration

  • - Long half-life (months/years)

  • - Repeated administration (continuous infusion for non-IgG-like)

  • - Short/intermediate half-life (hours/days)

Tissue penetration
  • - Homing of the T cells for blood, lymph nodes, and bone marrow

  • - Non IgG like: enhanced tissue penetration

Toxicity
  • - Acute reversible neurotoxicity (CD19)

  • - Cytokine release syndrome (CRS)

  • - Lower toxicity expected

  • - Acute reversible neurotoxicity (CD19)

  • - Cytokine release syndrome (CRS)

Main diseases
  • - Outstanding activity in some hematological malignancies: B cell acute lymphoblastic leukemia, Diffuse Large B cell lymphoma (CD19)

  • - Clinical trials in solid tumors

  • - B cell acute lymphoblastic leukemia (CD19)

  • - Clinical trials for many solid tumors including colorectal, ovarian, breast and prostate cancer

Other limitations
  • - Clinical activity in solid tumors is still to demonstrate

  • - Immunosuppressive microenvironment (rationale for combination with ICIs or use of optimized CAR T-cells)

  • - Target specificity: risk of escape by loss of the target

  • - Clinical activity in solid tumors is still to demonstrate

  • - Immunosuppressive microenvironment (rationale for combination with ICIs)

  • - Target specificity: risk of escape by loss of the target

Cost and availability
  • - Long process, manufacturing issues

  • - Cost+++

  • - Immediate availability, less manufacturing and regulatory issues

  • - Cost+