Wildiers 2009b.
Methods | Accrual: 22 September 2005 to 18 July 2006 Multicentre, phase II randomised controlled trial conducted in Belgium Adjuvant therapy Median follow‐up: not reported |
|
Participants | Age: mean 49.2 years (SD 10.0) (arm 1); mean 48.6 years (SD 8.5) (arm 2) 51% (in both arms) were > 50 years of age Node‐positive or other features of high risk as per St Gallen criteria Stage I: 28% (arm 1), 5% (arm 2); stage II: 51% (arm 1), 79% (arm 2); stage III: 21% (arm 1), 15% (arm 2) Axillary lymph node involvement: mean 2.8 (SD 5.3) (arm 1), mean 4.2 (SD 6.9) (arm 2) ER‐positive: 64% (arm 1), 79% (arm 2); PR‐positive: 69% (arm 1), 79% (arm 2) HER2‐positive: not reported Excluded: prior systemic anti‐cancer therapy or radiotherapy |
|
Interventions | 4‐arm study with 1 treatment comparison presented as part of Wildiers 2009a (labelled as "conventional" in trial publication) and the other treatment comparison presented in Wildiers 2009b (labelled as "dose‐dense" in trial publication). Arm 1 ('arm D' in the trial publication): docetaxel (75 mg/m²) every 2 weeks for 4 cycles followed by fluorouracil (375 mg/m²), epirubicin (75 mg/m²), cyclophosphamide (375 mg/m²) every 10 or 11 days for 4 cycles. Arm 2 ('arm C' in the trial publication): fluorouracil (375 mg/m²), epirubicin (75 mg/m²), cyclophosphamide (375 mg/m²) every 10 or 11 days for 4 cycles followed by docetaxel (75 mg/m²) every 2 weeks for 4 cycles. For both arms: pegfilgrastim allowed for secondary prophylaxis of febrile neutropenia or prolonged grade IV neutropenia |
|
Outcomes | Primary outcome
Secondary outcomes
|
|
Notes | Clinical trial registration record not found Funding considerations: study and trial publication were supported by an Amgen grant. |
|
Risk of bias | ||
Bias | Authors' judgement | Support for judgement |
Random sequence generation (selection bias) | Low risk | Quote: "patients were randomized…(1:1:2:2)." Comment: this process involved stratified randomisation for age (< or > 50 years of age). Baseline characteristics were similar across groups and no major imbalances were noted (e.g. for age, white blood cell count, tumour parameters). |
Allocation concealment (selection bias) | Low risk | Central allocation Quote: "…Randomisation of patients was carried out centrally via email or fax…" |
Blinding of participants and personnel (performance bias) All outcomes | Low risk | Open‐label study. Participants in both groups received the same drugs though in different order. Therefore, it was unlikely that this would lead to material bias in participants' and physicians' behaviours even when unblinded. |
Blinding of outcome assessment (detection bias) Toxicity and treatment adherence | Low risk | Study used formalised toxicity criteria (NCI CTC) and the limited number of toxicity outcomes reported (i.e. neutropenia) were based on objective measures from blood tests. Dose‐reductions/delays were based on this toxicity assessment. Given the types of toxicities assessed in this study, unblinding was unlikely to influence the physicians' assessments. |
Incomplete outcome data (attrition bias) All outcomes | Low risk | 92% (36/39) of participants in dose‐dense Doc → FEC (docetaxel → fluorouracil, epirubicin, cyclophosphamide) arm and 97% (38/39) of participants in dose‐dense FEC → Doc (fluorouracil, epirubicin, cyclophosphamide → docetaxel) arm completed the study. 3 withdrawals related to adverse events and 1 due to the physician’s decision. |
Selective reporting (reporting bias) | Low risk | Could not identify clinical trial registry record (trial started recruitment in September 2005 and completed in July 2006). However, all outcomes reported in the Methods section had the corresponding results in the publication. |
Other bias | Low risk | None identified |
ANC: absolute neutrophil count; DFS: disease‐free survival; ER: oestrogen receptor; FACT‐B: Functional Assessment of Cancer Therapy – Breast Cancer; G‐CSF: granulocyte‐colony stimulating factor; HER2: human epidermal growth factor receptor 2; ITT: intention to treat; LVEF: left ventricular ejection fraction; NCI CTC: National Cancer Institute Common Toxicity Criteria for Adverse Events; OS: overall survival; pCR: pathological complete response; PR: progesterone receptor; RDI: relative dose intensity; SD: standard deviation.