Table 1.
Reference | No. Pts. | RPLND Template | Adjuvant Chemotherapy (%) | Follow-up (months) | Relapse rate (%) | Death rate (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Stage I NSGCT | ||||||
Richie et al. 1990[14] | 85 | Unilateral | 15 | 38 (median) | 6 PS I; 15 PS II | 0 |
Donohue et al.1993[12] | 378* | Bilateral and unilateral | 13 | 71.3 (mean) | 12 PS I; 34 PS II without Cx; 0 PS II with Cx | 0.8 |
Hermans et al. 2000[7] | 292 | NA | 12 | 46 (median) | 10 PS I; 23 PS II without Cx; 0 PS II with Cx | 0.3 |
Stephens on et al. 2005[13] | 297 | Bilateral and unilateral | 15 | 59 (median) | 6 PS I; 19 PS II | 0 |
Albers et al. 2008[10] | 173 | Unilateral | 18 | 56 (median) | 9 Overall | 0 |
Stage II NSGCT | ||||||
Donohue et al. 1995[21] | 140* | Bilateral and unilateral | 42 | 132 (mean) | 6 PS I; 37 PS II without Cx; 0 PS II with Cx | 2 |
Weissbach et al. 2000[22] | 109 | Bilateral and unilateral | 88 | 36 (median) | 23 PS I; 5 PS II-III with Cx | 0 |
Stephens on et al. 2007[20] | 136 | Bilateral and unilateral | 49 | 63 (median) | 21 overall at 5-year | 2 at 5-year |
Stage I-II Seminoma | ||||||
Warszawski et al. 1997[28] | 45 CS I; 18 CSII | Bilateral | 0 | 79 (median) | 7 PS I, 33 PS II | 8 at 5-years |
Mezvrishvili etal. 2006[29] | IOCS I; 4 CS II | Unilateral | 0 | 56 (mean) | 0 | 0 |
Hu et al. 2015[30] | 4CS II | Unilateral | 0 | 25 (mean) | 0 | 0 |
RPLND = retroperitoneal lymph node dissection; NSGCT = non-seminoma germ cell tumor; PS = pathologic stage; Cx = chemotherapy; NA = not available; CS = clinical stage
Includes patients treated after 1979.