Skip to main content
. 2019 Feb 11;15(2):e1006785. doi: 10.1371/journal.pcbi.1006785

Table 2. Forecasting metrics and scores of the best semi-mechanistic model variant compared to null models.

The values shown are the same scores as in Fig 3, for forecasting horizons up to three weeks. The p-values for calibration highlighted in bold reflect predictive models with no evidence of miscalibration.

Model Calibration Sharpness Bias RPS DSS AE
1 week ahead
 Semi-mechanistic 0.26 91 0.13 31 9.2 42
 Autoregressive 0.1 61 -0.17 31 9.1 43
 Deterministic 0.03 340 0.24 97 11 130
 Unfocused <0.01 41 -0.024 35 13 47
2 weeks ahead
 Semi-mechanistic 0.14 150 0.2 50 12 65
 Autoregressive 0.03 77 -0.18 43 9.9 60
 Deterministic <0.01 400 0.35 120 12 160
 Unfocused <0.01 42 -0.044 48 16 61
3 weeks ahead
 Semi-mechanistic 0.03 230 0.3 81 15 93
 Autoregressive 0.02 90 -0.17 53 11 73
 Deterministic <0.01 490 0.45 160 13 210
 Unfocused <0.01 44 -0.058 60 29 71