Table 3.
Respondent | Third‐order constructs | All papers | High‐“quality” papers |
---|---|---|---|
Initiation of engagement | |||
Children | Self‐motivation, recognition of own needs | Cater (2014) | Cater (2014) |
Understanding and acknowledgement of DVA | |||
Children might not understand that DVA is the root cause of their involvement with an intervention | |||
Children | Adjustment to the “new reality” in their lives | Peled (1998) | Peled (1998) |
Children | Acknowledging DVA had been a part of their lives |
Peled (1998) Jarman (2014) |
Peled (1998) |
Children | DVA, and engagement with a DVA‐focused intervention, may be of marginal concern to children who may be engaged with other normal developmental milestones or other immediate family traumas |
Peled (1998) Thompson (2011) |
Peled (1998) Thompson (2011) |
Children | Learning the violence vocabulary |
Paris (1999) Peled and Edleson (1992) |
Paris (1999) Peled and Edleson (1992) |
Children | Defining or labelling abuse |
Peled and Edleson (1992) Paris (1999) Peled (1998) |
Peled and Edleson (1992) Paris (1999) Peled (1998) |
Children | Attribution of responsibility for DVA |
Peled (1998) Peled and Edleson (1992) Jarman (2014) |
Peled (1998) Peled and Edleson (1992) |
Children | Recognising equality of gender roles | Jarman (2014) | |
Recognising the effect of DVA on mothers and other children and having empathy | |||
Children | Empathy for mother's situation | Peled (1998) | Peled (1998) |
Children | Recognising their mother's strength | Jarman (2014) | |
Children | Development of empathy | Thompson (2011) | Thompson (2011) |
Breaking the secret | |||
Children | Helping mothers and other children [altruism as motivation for joining in] | Humphreys et al. (2011) | Humphreys et al. (2011) |
Breaking the secret was difficult for children/children did not want to talk about the past or their fathers. Children felt their situation to be shameful/the presence of nonabusive parent (mother) helped children with the activities | |||
Children |
Not wanting to talk about the past/violence Not wanting to talk about their fathers |
Humphreys et al. (2011) Peled (1998) Jarman (2013) Cater (2014) |
Humphreys et al. (2011) Peled (1998) Cater (2014) |
Children | Hesitancy to share what has happened |
Thompson (2009) Paris (1999) |
Thompson (2009) Paris (1999) |
Children | Readiness to talk |
Paris (1999) Peled and Edleson (1992) Thompson (2011) Thompson (2009) |
Paris (1999) Peled and Edleson (1992) Thompson (2011) Thompson (2009) |
Children |
“I am not alone”: Beneficial; release of stress particularly beneficial to children who have not spoken of it before Reducing shame and guilt |
Peled and Edleson (1992) Thompson (2011) Ermentrout et al. (2014) |
Peled and Edleson (1992) Thompson (2011) Ermentrout et al. (2014) |
Children | Child perception of benefits |
Humphreys et al. (2011) Paris (1999) Jarman (2014) |
Humphreys et al. (2011) Paris (1999) Jarman (2014) |
Children | Building trust between practitioner and child, helps break the secret | Cater (2014) | Cater (2014) |
Children | Therapeutic relationship can assist engagement | Cater (2014) | Cater (2014) |
Children | Children must be motivated if intervention is to work | Cater (2014) | Cater (2014) |
Readiness to “Break the secret” | |||
Children | Differential readiness between parents and children as a barrier to uptake | Cater (2014) | Cater (2014) |
Children | Mothers do not understand child needs, older children use own initiative to seek help | Cater (2014) | Cater (2014) |
Children | Initiation driven by adult assumption of child needs | Cater (2014) | Cater (2014) |
Children | Children's participation may be aided by involving them in decision to take up a programme | Cater (2014) | Cater (2014) |
Children | Child must be motivated if participation is to work | Cater (2014) | Cater (2014) |