Skip to main content
. 2019 Feb 19;19(4):1–166.

Table A4:

Risk of Biasa Among Test Accuracy Studies (QUADAS-2 Tool)

  Risk of Bias Applicability Concerns
Author, Year Patient Selection Index Test Reference Standard Flow and Timing Patient Selection Index Test Reference Standard
Bianchi et al, 201452 Highb Low Low Highc Highd Low Low
del Mar Gil et al, 201453 Uncleare Low Low Highc Low Low Low
Langlois et al, 201754 Highb Low Low Low Low Low Low
Nicolaides et al, 201255 Highb Low Low Highc Low Low Low
Norton et al, 201556 Highb Low Low Highc Low Low Low
Palomaki et al, 201757 Highb Low Low Highc Low Low Low
Quezada et al, 201558 Highb Low Unclearf Highc Low Low Low
Song et al, 201359 Highb Low Low Highc Low Low Low

Abbreviation: NIPT, noninvasive prenatal testing; QUADAS-2; Quality Assessment of Diagnostic Accuracy Studies.

a

Possible risk of bias levels: low, high, unclear.

b

Did not avoid inappropriate exclusions or had unclear consecutive or random enrolment of patients.

c

Inappropriate interval between NIPT and reference standard. Some studies missing or excluded patients in analysis.

d

Applicability concerns because of inappropriate patient exclusions.

e

Unclear patient enrolment and study exclusions.

f

Unclear whether reference standard was interpreted without knowledge of NIPT results.