Skip to main content
. 2019 Mar 4;9:3330. doi: 10.1038/s41598-019-40119-2

Table 2.

The significance probability (p - value; F- ratio), lack of fit and coefficients of determination of second order polynomial models that demonstrated the relationship between the experimental and response factors as refined by the BBD.

OPE Linear effects Linear interactions Quadratic interactions Model LOF r 2 radj2
A B C AB AC BC AA BB CC
TEP RC −6578.31 −5362.24 68725.90 −41.71 67.82 −1.24 −86.11 −128.51 −123.33 −8.54E6 0.9090 0.7453
F-ratio 2.51 7.41 0.18 1.08 0.40 0.00 1.07 37.96 0.69 5.69
p-value 0.1741 0.0417 0.6885 0.3457 0.5536 0.9823 0.3493 0.0016 0.4435 0.0368 0.1570
TPP RC −20214.10 21629.90 192765.00 3.94 224.25 −71.02 −266.10 −127.83 −355.49 −2.32E7 0.7661 0.3450
F-ratio 4.43 4.40 0.03 0.00 0.61 0.25 1.41 5.21 0.80 1.36
p-value 0.0893 0.0901 0.8646 0.9722 0.4699 0.6416 0.2882 0.0713 0.4129 0.2641 0.4840
TNBP RC −7979.85 21520.60 131141.00 41.30 139.35 −70.44 −189.86 −54.09 −241.67 −1.59E7 0.7720 0.3615
F-ratio 4.42 7.47 0.02 0.31 0.50 0.51 1.51 1.96 0.77 0.91
p-value 0.0895 0.0412 0.9000 0.6018 0.5127 0.5083 0.2737 0.2202 0.4191 0.2520 0.6070
TCEP RC 7444.20 4191.35 11763.40 30.20 1.54 −13.45 −40.86 −6.84 −20.55 −1.42E6 0.9404 0.8332
F-ratio 13.48 53.65 0.06 6.93 0.00 0.77 2.93 1.31 0.23 2.00
p-value 0.0144 0.0007 0.8197 0.0463 0.9619 0.4194 0.1477 0.3037 0.6488 0.0139 0.3710
TCIPP RC −23.90 3572.82 12392.20 7.90 13.15 −12.09 −21.58 −3.74 −23.40 −1.45E6 0.7846 0.3969
F-ratio 4.83 8.45 0.06 0.89 0.35 1.17 1.53 0.73 0.57 0.74
p-value 0.0794 0.0335 0.8237 0.3896 0.5822 0.3291 0.2716 0.4310 0.4850 0.2264 0.6720
TDCIPP RC 2997.13 2853.14 12686.90 11.21 2.32 −8.71 −19.84 −4.52 −21.63 −1.77E6 0.9553 0.8747
F-ratio 15.32 75.02 1.58 5.42 0.03 1.84 3.92 3.25 1.47 1.77
p-value 0.0113 0.0003 0.2645 0.0673 0.8636 0.2326 0.1046 0.1313 0.2789 0.0070 0.4040
TBOEP RC 5088.09 1724.69 8810.79 17.75 −4.76 −5.82 −17.27 −3.39 −13.68 −1.37E6 0.9724 0.9228
F-ratio 30.49 114.02 5.20 18.73 0.19 1.13 4.10 2.52 0.81 3.46
p-value 0.0027 0.0001 0.0715 0.0075 0.6816 0.3360 0.0989 0.1730 0.4085 0.0022 0.2410
TPHP RC 11657.50 14648.60 71805.70 50.75 12.85 −47.80 −79.65 −16.74 −121.79 −1.02E7 0.9334 0.8134
F-ratio 12.35 43.24 2.51 4.39 0.04 2.19 2.50 1.77 1.85 1.09
p-value 0.0170 0.0012 0.1740 0.0902 0.8500 0.1987 0.1748 0.2414 0.2321 0.0180 0.5520
EHDPP RC 45358.80 21252.60 135283.00 155.24 −12.61 −71.20 −224.65 −39.05 −229.32 −1.93E7 0.9714 0.9200
F-ratio 28.33 110.25 1.02 16.13 0.01 1.91 7.79 3.77 2.57 1.87
p-value 0.0031 0.0001 0.3584 0.0102 0.9074 0.2256 0.0384 0.1099 0.1698 0.0024 0.3890
TEHP RC 12887.70 77284.80 417801.00 306.78 343.72 −261.83 −670.97 −113.61 −752.44 −5.49E7 0.9354 0.8193
F-ratio 11.92 41.94 0.52 5.34 0.94 2.19 5.90 2.71 2.35 1.64
p-value 0.0182 0.0013 0.5017 0.0687 0.3760 0.1990 0.0595 0.1609 0.1860 0.0167 0.4260

RC: Regression coefficient, A, B and C are the experimental factors, desorption flow, cryofocusing temperature and cryodesorption temperature, respectively. LOF refers to Lack of fit.