Table 1.
Study | Number (Exp/Con) | Gender (Exp/Con) | Age (Exp/Con) | Course of disease/ year (Exp/Con) | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Qing Shi 2018[21] | 93 | 93 | 50/43 | 54/39 | 60.21±3.97 | 59.43±3.65 | - | - |
Wenjun Gao 2018[22] | 40 | 40 | 24/16 | 22/18 | 64.92±6.40 | 65.28±6.39 | 6.18 ±1.23 | 6.20 ±1.21 |
Chunyan Xue 2017[23] | 40 | 40 | 28/12 | 26/14 | 61.35±2.64 | 61.42±2.71 | - | - |
Guangzhi Li 2017[24] | 44 | 39 | 32/12 | 27/12 | 71.05±3.83 | 72.67±4.17 | 15.12±3.95 | 14.26 ± 4. 97 |
Jianhua Guo 2016[25] | 70 | 70 | 43/27 | 46/24 | 77.60±5.40 | 76.80±5.30 | 9.20±0.30 | 11.50±0.50 |
Jing Feng 2016[26] | 260 | 260 | 165/95 | 157/103 | 63.88±2.85 | 63.85±2.79 | 5.88±4.70 | 5.81±2.79 |
Qianfan Zhao 2016[27] | 60 | 60 | 32/28 | 33/27 | 53.25±7.15 | 54.60±7.25 | 6.34±2.79 | 6.53±2.68 |
Yunyu Zhou 2016[28] | 30 | 30 | 18/12 | 17/13 | 60.40±5.20 | 61.50±5.10 | - | - |
Yingjie Li 2016[29] | 60 | 60 | 38/22 | 36/24 | 73.3±3.5 | 72.7±3.6 | - | - |
Yihao Wang 2016 [30] | 48 | 48 | 60/36 | 62.30±5.40 | - | - | ||
Yongjie Qiao 2016[31] | 40 | 40 | 28/12 | 26/14 | 52.36±12.67 | 53.06±13.04 | 7. 89±2. 86 | 8. 17±2. 44 |
Lingzhun Wang 2016[32] | 30 | 30 | 37/23 | 65.12±9.760 | 5.35±1.56 | |||
Qicai Fan 2015[33] | 48 | 42 | 30/18 | 28/14 | 60.80±5.80 | 62.30±8.60 | - | - |
Wei Xu 2015[34] | 46 | 46 | 29/17 | 31/15 | 65.89±7.21 | 66.14±6.58 | 5.72±3.96 | 6.41±4.08 |
Hengdong Liu 2015[35] | 33 | 33 | 18/15 | 17/16 | 70.30±2.30 | 70.50±2.10 | 5.50± 1.20 | 5.4 0± 1.30 |
Zhimei Huang 2015[36] | 90 | 78 | 48/42 | 42/36 | 74.20±4.10 | 73.70±4.30 | 3.30± 1.20 | 3.50± 1.50 |
Jing Li 2015[37] | 55 | 55 | 38/17 | 36/19 | 56.58±6.36 | 57.32±6.33 | 5.23±0.78 | 5.41±0.72 |
Lei Xie 2014[38] | 40 | 40 | 23/17 | 25/15 | 46.00±87.00 | 42.00±86.00 | - | - |
Ting Li 2014[39] | 85 | 52 | 52/33 | 37/15 | 68.20±2.40 | 64.90±3.20 | 13.70±1.50 | 11.50±1.80 |
Hongbin Cai 2013[40] | 34 | 35 | 17/17 | 20/15 | 56.79±5.89 | 57.02±7.50 | 12.77±5.30 | 11.89±4.39 |
Yongping Hu 2012[41] | 35 | 35 | 17/18 | 19/17 | 55.54±5.42 | 52.46±5.01 | - | - |
Tingzhu Wu 2010[42] | 43 | 37 | 48/32 | 65.10±10.40 | - | - |