Skip to main content
. 2019 Feb 28;13:84. doi: 10.3389/fnins.2019.00084

Table 4.

Relation of fNIRS and cortical excitability as measured by TMS: motor mapping, functional MEPs, and central fatigue.

References Population Task Stimulation Parameters Stimulation Area Measurement Area No. of Subjects Finding
Motor Mapping Park et al., 2004 Stroke-Paresis Key Turning 110%RMT for Motor Mapping L/R-M1 Bilateral-M1 Case Study (Stroke) Decreased [HbO], increased lateralization during task over therapy. Enlarged motor region after therapy.
Akiyama et al., 2006 Healthy Hand Grasping 120%RMT for Motor Mapping L-M1 L-M1 10 HC Biphasic [HbO] changes observed over MEP COG
Koenraadt et al., 2011 Healthy Thumb abduction 120%RMT for Motor Mapping L-M1 L-M1 11 HC No difference in [HbO] changes at MEP COG vs C3
MEP during Task Lo et al., 2009 Healthy Reading aloud, Singing 110%RMT, random MEP evaluation during task L-M1 L-M1 5 HC Changes in evoked MEP amplitude during vocalization at MEP COG, MEP changes not correlated with [HbO]
Derosière et al., 2015 Healthy Sustained Attention MEP evaluated at 5min intervals L-M1 PFC, L-M1, R-Parietal 15 TMS, 13 fNIRS, 4 Control Increase in lateral PFC and right parietal [HbO], MEP amplitude increase over TOT
Corp et al., 2018 Elderly Dual Task [Tapping, N-Back] MEP evaluated at 12.5s intervals L-M1 Exp1: PFC (Online),
Exp2: PFC, PM, M1
Exp1: 15 Young, 15 Eld.
Exp2: 15 Eld.
Increased CSP during dual-tasks in elderly correlated with worse performance. fNIRS uncorrelated with dual-task performance
Exercise & Fatigue Millet et al., 2012 Healthy Isometric elbow contraction MEP and CSP evaluation every 4th contraction R-M1 L-DLPFC Exp1: 12 HC,
Exp2: 10 HC
Reduced performance and prefrontal oxygenation in hypoxia despite normoxia in muscle. Similar CSP and MEP responses
Goodall et al., 2012 Healthy Cycling MEP, CSP, VA evaluation at 130%RMT before and after exercise L-M1 L-DLPFC 9 HC Reduced performance and prefrontal oxygenation in hypoxia and larger decrease in VA TMS after exercise
Goodall et al., 2014 Healthy Cycling MEP, CSP, VA evaluation at 130%RMT before and after exercise L-M1 L-DLPFC 7 HC Greater decrease in prefrontal oxygenation in acute hypoxia, decrease in voluntary and potentiated force in both chronic and acute hypoxia. Doubled MEP size in chronic hypoxia.
Rupp et al., 2015 Healthy Isometric knee contraction MEP, VA, CSP evaluated before and during contractions L-M1 L-DLPFC 15 HC Reduced performance in hypoxia, increased prefrontal oxygenation in hypoxia with CO2 clamping vs. w/o, VA TMS decrease greater in hypoxia w/o CO2 clamping
Jubeau et al., 2017 Healthy Cycling MEP, VA, CSP evaluated before and 1,2,3 hours after exercise L-M1 L-DLPFC, L-M1 10 HC No performance difference, VA TMS or CSP after prolonged exercise in hypoxia conditions, reduced prefrontal oxygenation in hypoxia
Marillier et al., 2017 Healthy Isometric elbow contraction MEP, VA, CSP evaluated before and during contractions L-M1 L-DLPFC 11 HC No performance differences between acute, chronic, or normoxia conditions or in VA TMS decline.
Longer CSP in hypoxia conditions. No difference in prefrontal or muscle oxygenation
Laurent et al., 2018 Healthy Isometric knee extension MEP, VA evaluated at 140% 'optimal' power, before and during extension, and after task failure L-M1 L-DLPFC 14 Trained Athletes No effect of salbutamol intake on VA TMS, prefrontal oxygenation, or task performance
Solianik et al., 2018 Healthy 2 Hr Speed-Accuracy Motor task MEP evaluation at 130%RMT before and after task L-M1 DLPFC 10 HC Increased MEP amplitude after prolonged activity, decrease in evoked left-prefrontal [Hb] in Stroop task vs. pre-task Stroop, no change for control activity