Table 2.
Key | Dataset(s) origin | Dataset(s) type | Dataset(s) length | Scope | Biomarker(s) type | Pre-processing (if any) | Validation (if any) | Model(s) tested | Performance |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Gordon et al., 2009 | Eleanor and Lou Gehrig MDA/ALS Research Center |
Real-life | 34 | ALS, UMN, PLS |
Clinical | FS | None described | Linear regression | - |
Srivastava et al., 2012 | Boston Children Hospital | Real-life | 46 | SMA phenotypes | Clinical, genetic | FS | CV | SVM | AUC (0.928) |
Welsh et al., 2013 | Michigan MND Clinic | Real-life | 63 | ALS, healthy | Imaging | FS | LOOV | SVM | AUC:0.7, Acc:71%, Spec:74%, Sens:68.8% |
Sarica et al., 2016 | Catanzaro Magna Graecia University | Real-life | 48 | ALS, healthy | Clinical, imaging | SP, FS | CV | RF | Acc:80% |
Schuster et al., 2016b | Trinity College Dublin | Real-life | 147 | ALS, healthy | Imaging | SP, FS | CV | Logistic regression | Acc:78.4%, raji Sens:90.5%, rajiSpec:62.5% |
Bede et al., 2017 | Trinity College Dublin | Real-life | 150 | ALS, healthy | Imaging | SP, FS | HOV | Discriminant function | Acc:90%, Sens:90%, Spec:90% |
Ferraro et al., 2017 | MND Clinics in Northern Italy |
Real-life | 265 | ALS, UMN, ALS mimics |
Imaging | SP | HOV | RF | Acc:87%, Spec:75%, Sens:92% |
Fratello et al., 2017 | UK PD Brain Bank | Real-life | 120 | ALS, PD, healthy |
Imaging | SP, FS | CV | RF | Acc:80% |
D'hulst et al., 2018 | University Hospital rajiLeuven and Turino ALS Center |
Real-life | 370 | ALS, healthy | Imaging | SP | LOOV | SVM | Acc:80%, Sens:85%, Spec:12.5% |
Li et al., 2018 | Australia | Clinical trial | 81 | ALS, KD, ALS mimics |
Clinical | FS | None described | Linear regression | Acc:77.5%, Sens:68%, Spec:87% |
Querin et al., 2018 | Pitiè Salpêtrière Hospital | Real-life | 105 | ALS, healthy | Imaging | SP | CV | RF | AUC:0.96, Acc:86.5%, Sens:88%, Spec:85% |
CV, Cross Validation; LOOV, Leave One Out Validation; HOV, Hold Out Validation; AUC, Area under the ROC Curve; Acc, Accuracy; Sens, Sensitivity; Spec, Specificity; PD, Parkinson's Disease; FS, Feature Selection; SP, Signal Processing.