Table 3.
Key | Dataset(s) origin | Dataset(s) type | Dataset(s) length | Scope | Biomarker(s) type | Pre-processing (if any) | Validation (if any) | Model(s) tested |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Ince et al., 2003 | Newcastle upon rajiTyne MND clinic |
Real-life | 81 | Progression | Imaging | None described | Not required | Univariate analysis |
Forbes, 2004 | Scottish ALS-MND Register | Population | 1226 | Outcome | Clinical | None described | Not required | Cox time rajidependent regression modeling |
Visser et al., 2007 | Dutch university hospitals | Real-life | 37 | Outcome | Clinical, genetic, biological | None described | Not required | Univariate analysis |
Coon et al., 2011 | Mayo Clinic | Real-life | 56 | Outcome | Clinical, imaging | None described | Not required | KM analysis |
Atassi et al., 2014 | PRO-ACT | Clinical trial | 8635 | Outcome, progression | Clinical, biological | Data cleaning | Not required | Multivariate analysis |
Elamin et al., 2015 | Irish and Italian (Piemonte) ALS registry | Population | 326 | Outcome | Clinical, genetic |
FS | HOV | Proportional hazards Cox |
Marin et al., 2015 | FRALim register | Population | 322 | Outcome | Clinical | None described | Not required | Cox regression (KM) |
Rong et al., 2015 | - | Clinical trial | 66 | Progression | Clinical | FS | Not required | Linear Mixed Effect, KM analysis |
Tortelli et al., 2015 | University of Bari MND Center |
Clinical trial | 145 | Outcome | Clinical | None described | Not required | Bivariate model for correlation |
Wolf et al., 2015 | Rhineland-Palatinate Register | Population | 193 | Outcome | Clinical | FS | Not required | Cox proportional hazards |
Knibb et al., 2016 | South-East England Register | Population | 575 | Outcome, progression | Clinical | MVR | CV | Cox proportional hazards, ACT |
Reniers et al., 2017 | University Hospitals Leuven | Real-life | 396 | Outcome | Clinical | None described | Not required | Univariate and multivariate Cox regression |
HOV, Hold Out Validation; CV, Cross Validation; ACT, Accelerated Failure Time; KM, Kaplan Meier; MVR, Missing Value Removal; FS, Feature Selection.