Table 10.
Study | Country | Intervention | Comparator | Study design | Follow-up | n | Induction of clinical remission |
Schmidt et al[30] | Germany | Tacrolimus | - | Retrospective cohort | 24 mo | 58 | 51%1 |
Tacrolimus with purine analogues | - | Retrospective cohort | 24 mo | 79 | 82%1 | ||
Llaó et al[31] | Spain | IV corticosteroids | - | Retrospective cohort | 3 d | 110 | 52%2 |
IV corticosteroids | - | Retrospective cohort | 7 d | 110 | 75% 2 | ||
Campbell et al[35] | UK | Cyclosporine | - | Retrospective cohort | Acute phase | 76 | 74%3 |
Sood et al[33] | India | AZA | Placebo | RCT | 1 yr | 83 | 56% (AZA); 40% (placebo)4 |
Prieux-Klotz et al[37] | France | AZA or 6-MP | Retrospective cohort | 38 mo | 80 | 61.2%5 | |
Yamamoto et al[38] | Japan | Tacrolimus | Anti-TNF | Retrospective | 12 wk | 100 | 40% (tacrolimus); 28% (anti-TNF); P = 0.296 |
Ogata et al[39] | Japan | Tacrolimus | Placebo | RCT | 2 wk | 62 | 9.4% (tacrolimus); 0% (placebo); P = 0.2387 |
Tacrolimus | Placebo | RCT | 12 wk | 21 | 28.6% (tacrolimus)7 | ||
Hyde et al[44] | United Kingdom | Hydrocortisone | - | Retrospective cohort | 5 d | 216 | 61%8 |
Cyclosporine | - | Retrospective cohort | 4.5 d | 50 | 56%8 | ||
Kjeldsen et al[43] | Denmark | Prednisolone | - | Retrospective cohort | 6 wk | 51 | 47% (severe disease); 80% (moderate disease)9 |
Meyers et al[42] | United States | ACTH | Hydrocortisone | RCT | 10 d | 66 | 44% (ACTH); 41% (Hydrocortisone)10 |
Clinical remission defined by a Lichtiger score ≤ 3;
Clinical remission defined as mild activity or inactive disease according to the Montreal severity score, with no need for rescue treatment at day 7 after starting intravenous CS;
Response defined as a reduction of bowel frequency to fewer than three daily and a C-reactive protein < 45 mg/L;
Clinical remission defined as clinical improvement with absent of symptoms of active disease (rectal bleeding, bowel frequency) with sigmoidoscopic appearance of grade 0-1 and normal histological pattern;
Clinical remission defined as a partial Mayo Clinic score ≤ 2 without any clinical subscore > 1;
Clinical remission defined as a score of 0 in the clinical section (both stool frequency and rectal bleeding);
Clinical remission was defined as a total DAI score ≤ 2 with an individual subscore of 0 or 1;
Clinical remission defined as bowel frequency less than three stools per day, no visible blood, no fever or pain;
Remission was assessed in accordance with a modified Truelove and Witts index;
Remission defined as patient receiving no therapy or only prophylactic sulfasalazine. 6-MP: 6-mercaptopurine; ACTH: Adrenocorticotrophic hormone; AZA: Azathioprine; CI: Confidence interval; IV: Intravenous; MTX: Methotrexate; n: Number of patients; RCT: Randomized clinical trial; TNF: Tumor necrosis factor; DAI: Disease Activity Index.