Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2019 Mar 12.
Published in final edited form as: Curr Transplant Rep. 2018 Feb 5;5(1):27–44. doi: 10.1007/s40472-018-0181-1

Table 1.

Description of programs evaluated in clinical trials

Program Additional Program Description
“House Calls” or Home-Based Education Program, (Rodrigue et al, 2007 & 2014) 10,39
  • HB intervention in which trained health educators perform 60 to 90-minute LDKT education session with family and members of the candidate’s social network.

  • Sessions may be held in an alternative setting (e.g., another residence, local library) if the patient is uncomfortable hosting the session or if a larger setting is needed to accommodate more guests.

  • Goals are to (a) increase transplantation and living donation knowledge and awareness among members of the patient's social network who are unable or unlikely to attend clinic-based educational sessions, and (b) jump-start the discussion about LDKT and living donation.

  • For most members of the patient’s social network, HB education may be their first opportunity to learn about LDKT, and to have their questions answered by a transplant health educator. More knowledge among social network members may facilitate discussions about LDKT and reduce patients’ hesitancy to discuss the topic with others.

  • HB education for black patients included at least 1 minority educator and incorporation of race-specific transplant statistics into discussion, and written brochures highlighted minority recipients and their donors.

  • In the first (~1 hour) session, the candidate’s social network is diagrammed in order to facilitate understanding of the candidate’s social system, and to guide the candidate in formulating a list of invitees to the second session.11

  • In the second (~2.5 hour) session, which includes the transplant candidate’s social network, the educators provide information on kidney disease, dialysis, LDKT, and living donation; stimulate open communication between the patient and family members; and seek to develop consensus on the patient’s goals and how the goals could be achieved with engagement and support of the social network.

“Kidney Team at Home” (Ismail et al, 2014; Massey et al, 2016)11,12
  • In this adaptation of “House Calls”, the HB intervention comprises 2 visits at the transplant candidate’s home. The first visit (1 hour) focuses solely on the patient, while the second visit (2 to 3 hours) includes the transplant candidates’ social network and explores the possibilities of LDKT.

“Talking About Live Kidney Donation” (TALK) and “TALK-Social Worker” Intervention Programs (Boulware et al, 2013; DePasquale et al, 2012)13,14
  • The 20-minute video includes ethnically diverse patients and families describing their experiences discussing and pursuing LDKT, and transplant professionals describing factors for patients/families to consider.

  • The booklet encourages patients not yet on dialysis to talk to family and health care providers about LDKT, with examples of model conversations and sources of additional information. Patients may review the video and booklet on their own or with a social worker.

  • Patients are encouraged to share the materials with members of their social network.

  • In the first “TALK-Social Worker” session, the social worker distributes the video and booklet and helps the patient identify barriers to considering or pursuing LDKT. The patient is asked to invite family/friends to a second session.

  • At the second session, the social worker helps social network members to identify barriers to LDKT and living donation and to describe prior discussions about living donation.

  • Problem-solving and motivational interviewing techniques are employed at both sessions.

“Living ACTS” (About Choices in Transplantation and Sharing) (Arriola et al, 2014)15
  • The program was based on a conceptual model that emphasizes the need to address both “surface” characteristics relevant to a given cultural group (e.g., by including people, places and language familiar to and preferred by the target audience) and more deeply rooted elements that may influence behavior (e.g., the influential roles that family discussion and family impact play in many African-Americans’ decisions regarding healthcare).

  • The video features African-American patients, families and healthcare professionals and addresses the impact of LDKT on families, how family decision making around living donation may occur, and financial resources for LDKT.

  • The booklet provides additional information such as web links and tips for starting conversations with family members. The intervention was designed to address inadequacies of existing educational efforts in addressing unique concerns and issues in African American patients that may serve as barriers to pursuit of LDKT.

“Infórmate” Culturally Targeted Website (Gordon et al, 2015 & 2016) 16,17
  • Focus groups with Hispanic kidney transplant candidates, living donors, dialysis patients, and members of the general public supported content development.

  • This culturally-targeted website is presented in Spanish and English and was designed to extend the Northwestern Memorial Hospital's Hispanic Kidney Transplant Program, which is a unique clinical program providing care to Hispanic transplant patients.

“Written Educational Materials followed by Structured Educational Session” (Barnieh et al, 2011) 18
  • This session, which includes 3 to 5 other patients and their invited family members, uses a problem-based learning format and is facilitated by a transplant nurse coordinator and nephrologist.

  • In addition to providing didactic information about the advantages and disadvantages of ESRD treatment options and living kidney donation, patients and family members form smaller groups to problem-solve common scenarios pertaining to LDKT. For instance, this includes finding strategies to overcome barriers to living donation and role playing how to ask others about living donation.

  • At the end of the session, there is a question and answer session with a LDKT recipient and former living kidney donor.

ESRD, end-stage renal disease; HB, home-based; LDKT, living donor kidney transplantation