Table 2.
No. | Our model Precision | Our model Recall | Our model F2 Score | K-means Precision | K-means Recall | K-means F2 Score |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | 70.69% | 98.48% | 91.30% | 43.08% | 68.92% | 61.54% |
2 | 82.10% | 99.74% | 95.63% | 93.61% | 48.52% | 53.69% |
3 | 56.90% | 91.32% | 81.46% | 16.20% | 58.86% | 38.56% |
4 | 83.57% | 99.77% | 96.04% | 94.00% | 46.21% | 51.44% |
5 | 82.80% | 99.34% | 95.52% | 91.17% | 71.04% | 74.32% |
6 | 73.86% | 98.50% | 92.34% | 78.70% | 68.51% | 70.33% |
7 | 83.10% | 99.39% | 95.64% | 91.50% | 66.78% | 70.60% |
8 | 83.55% | 99.37% | 95.74% | 89.44% | 52.63% | 57.35% |
9 | 64.47% | 97.30% | 88.31% | 63.78% | 53.10% | 54.94% |
10 | 72.42% | 98.66% | 91.99% | 72.42% | 63.30% | 64.93% |
11 | 73.32% | 99.42% | 92.81% | 79.89% | 68.11% | 70.18% |
12 | 79.50% | 99.53% | 94.76% | 81.04% | 68.47% | 70.66% |
13 | 66.39% | 95.35% | 87.70% | 49.58% | 66.79% | 62.45% |
14 | 85.88% | 99.68% | 96.58% | 95.43% | 46.34% | 51.65% |
15 | 71.35% | 89.38% | 85.08% | 73.48% | 54.89% | 57.82% |
16 | 68.33% | 97.63% | 89.91% | 65.84% | 60.89% | 61.82% |
17 | 59.08% | 86.48% | 79.14% | 40.65% | 61.70% | 55.90% |
18 | 73.13% | 99.22% | 92.61% | 84.52% | 56.67% | 60.67% |
19 | 65.46% | 98.89% | 89.72% | 65.23% | 67.06% | 66.69% |
20 | 70.04% | 99.44% | 91.74% | 57.37% | 62.13% | 61.12% |
∗The average Precision, Recall and F2 score of our model in test samples are 73.30, 97.34, and 91.20%, respectively; the average Precision, Recall and F2 score of K-means method in test samples are 71.35, 60.55, and 60.83%, respectively.