Temperature |
Human hand temperature |
PDMS or thin PVA |
Au |
Au |
0.6 V |
20~150 °C |
1.9 Ohm K−1
|
- |
100% |
- |
[42] |
Temperature |
Temperature |
PDMS |
AgNW |
Graphene |
10 V |
30~100 °C |
Nonlinear resistance response |
- |
50% |
100 |
[31] |
Temperature |
Endothelial layer |
Polyester fabric strip coated with PDMS |
Au |
Platinum (Pt) |
0.8 V |
0~120 °C |
2.7 Ohm K−1
|
0.01% |
- |
- |
[54] |
pressure |
Intraocular pressure (IOP) |
Parylene |
graphene-AgNW |
ecoflex (capacitive-type) |
- |
5~150 mmHg |
- |
Bending radius: 3.1 μm |
25% |
10,000 cycles with 25% strain |
[32] |
Pressure |
Cutaneous pressure |
Ecoflex |
Au |
Lead zirconate titanate (PbZr0.52Ti0.48O3, PZT) |
VG: 3.5 V VD: 0.1 V |
0.005~10 Pa |
1.36 μA Pa−1
|
14.8 mm bending radius |
30% |
1000 |
[3] |
Pressure |
Touch |
PET or Polyurethane |
Conductive carbon fabric |
CNT/PDMS porous |
0.1 V |
0.25~100 kPa |
- |
30 mm bending radius |
30% |
10 |
[39] |
Pressure |
Artery wrist pulse or acoustic vibrations |
PDMS |
Au |
Au NWs |
1.5 V |
13 Pa~50 kPa |
1.14 kPa−1
|
30 mm bending radius |
25% |
50,000 |
[36] |
Pressure |
Pressure |
PDMS and Epoxy (SU8) |
Au or AgNW/graphene |
Graphene |
VG: 25 V VD: 0.1 V |
250 Pa~3 Mpa |
2.05 × 10−4 kPa−1 (below 500 kPa), 9.43 × 10−6 kPa−1 (above 500 kPa) |
- |
- |
1000 |
[33] |
Strain |
Facial expressions |
PDMS |
Polyurethane-PEDOT:PSS |
Single-walled carbon nanotubes |
1 V |
1.6~3.6%, 10~100% |
62 (ΔR/R)/ε
|
3.60% |
100% |
Minimum 50 cycles for bending, 1000 cycles for stretching |
[34] |
Strain |
Heartbeats |
PDMS |
Graphene woven fabrics |
Graphene woven fabrics |
1 V |
under 0.2~30% |
1000 (ΔR/R)/ε
|
- |
30% |
- |
[86] |
Strain |
Stretch and pressure |
PDMS |
Eutectic Gallium Indium |
Single-walled carbon nanotubes-Ecoflex |
- |
~150% |
0.004 (ΔC/C)/ε
|
- |
150% |
- |
[69] |
Strain |
Joint movement (bending) |
Silicon elastomer (Dragonskin 10 + Thi-Vex silicon thickener + Slo-jo platinum silicon cure retarder) |
Silver wire |
Ionic fluid - silicon elastomer |
AC 5 V, 50~200 Hz |
~700% |
0.348 (ΔC/C)/ε
|
- |
700% |
minimum 20 cycles for stretching |
[92] |
Strain |
Bending |
PDMS coated Polystyrene |
Silver paste |
ZnSnO3 nanowires |
1.2 V |
~0.33% |
3740 (ΔI/I)/ε
|
0.33% |
No stretchability |
- |
[95] |
Strain |
Lymphedema |
Silicon rubber (Solaris) |
Cu |
Cu-PI (capacitive-type) |
- |
0~30% |
- |
- |
30% |
- |
[160] |
Strain |
Strain |
PET textile |
Carbon nanotube/reduced Graphene oxide |
ZnO Nanowire |
- |
Sensor limits of bacterium/μL |
- |
3~5% |
- |
100 bending cycles |
[83] |
Gas |
O2 (oxygen) |
Porous PTFE (porous polytetrafluoroethylene) |
Au |
High-purity 1-butyl-1-methylpyrrolidinium bis (trifluoro-methylsulfonyl)imide |
−1.4V |
0~21% |
0.48 uA/% |
Can be bent either convex or concave |
- |
- |
[117] |
Gas |
NO2 (nitrogen dioxide) |
PES (polyethersulfone) |
Cr/Au |
Graphene |
30 V |
0.5 to 40 ppm |
∆R/R0 = −40% (at 40 ppm N2) |
∆R/R0 = 5% under a bending strain of 1.4% |
- |
- |
[37] |
Gas |
NO2 (nitrogen dioxide) |
Paper |
Au |
NaNO2 treated PbS CQD |
4.1 V |
0.5 to 50 ppm |
0.41/ppm |
Bending angle of 70° |
- |
7% decrease in response under 5000 cyclic bending tests (Bending angle of 50°) |
[114] |
Gas |
Volatile compouds (ammonia, acetic acid) |
Plastic substrate |
Cr/Au |
Polypyrrole (Ppy) (functionalized by carboxyl group) |
−0.1~0.1 V |
0.1~100 ppm |
- |
Bending angle: 15° |
- |
- |
[163] |
Gas |
Dimethyl methylphosphonate (DMMP) |
PI or PDMS or parylene |
Graphene-AgNW |
Graphene (functionalized by polypyrrole (Ppy)) |
0.1 V |
5~25 ppm |
- |
- |
20% |
1000 cycles with 5% strain |
[18] |
Gas |
H2S, C2H5OH, H2
|
PI |
Ti/Au |
Graphene oxide |
- |
Graphene limits of bacterium/μL |
Toluene, Acetone, CO Ethanol at 20 PPM, Acetone at 20 ppm, H2S, H2 at 5–20 ppm |
A 30° bending angle |
- |
104 bending cycles |
[175] |
Bio |
Protein (Concanavalin A, Con A) |
PET or PDMS or parylene |
Graphene-AgNW |
Graphene (functionalized by mannosyl-pyrene) |
0.1 V |
1 mg/mL |
- |
Bending radius: 27 μm (bending strain: 2.59%) |
20% |
- |
[12] |
Bio |
Bacteria (E. coli, S. aureus, H. pylori) |
Silk fibroin film |
Cr/Au |
graphene (functionalized by antimicrobial peptides (AMPs)) |
- |
Detection limits of bacterium/μL |
100~108 CFU/mL |
- |
- |
- |
[159] |
Bio |
Lactate |
Temporary transfer tatto paper, GORETEX |
Ag/AgCl, conductive carbon |
lactate oxidase(LOx) |
0.05 V |
1 mM to 25 mM |
644.2 nA/mM at RT, 0.916 μA/mM at 37 °C |
Bending angle of 90° |
stretched at ~10% |
The bending/stretching test: 10 times |
[136] |
Bio |
D-glucose |
Polyimide film (2 μm) |
Cr/Au |
In2O3, glucose oxidase |
0.2~0.8 V |
100 μM to 4 mM |
- |
Bending radius of 837 (0.078~0.082%) |
- |
- |
[40] |
Bio |
Glucose |
PDMS, Polyimide, Parylene |
Graphene/AgNW |
Graphene, glucose oxidase |
0.1 V |
1 μM~10 mM |
- |
- |
∆R < 6% at 25% tensile strain (5000 cycles) |
∆R ~20% at 10,000 cycles of stretching |
[32] |
Bio |
Glucose, Lactate |
PDMS |
- |
Enzyme and chromogenic reagent |
- |
Glucose: 0~25 mM Lactage: 0~100 mM |
- |
5 cm bending radius |
Strain 30% |
- |
[177] |
Bio |
Salivary Uric acid |
PET |
Ag/AgCl |
Prussian-blue-graphite |
- |
Mouthguard limits of bacterium/μL |
2.45 μA/mM |
- |
- |
- |
[29] |
Ion |
Chloride, H+
|
PDMS |
- |
Enzyme and chromogenic reagent |
- |
Chloride: 0~625 μM pH: 5.0~8.5 |
- |
5 cm bending radius |
Strain 30% |
- |
[177] |
Ion |
Na+, K+
|
Textile |
Ecoflex-containing Ag/AgCl ink, MWCNT |
Multi-walled carbon nanotubes (functionalized by carboxylic acid) |
- |
Physiological range of human sweat (10~110 × 10−3 M NaCl, 1~8 × 10−3 M KCl) |
54.1 ± 1.5 mV/log [Na+], 56.9 ± 1.6 mV/log [K+] |
Bending angle of 180° |
100 % (uniaxial stretching) |
No sensitivity degradation at linear strain of 75% during 60 min at a speed of 1 mm/s |
[122] |
Ion |
Na+, K+
|
PET (polyethylene terephthalate) |
Cr/Au, Ag/AgCl |
Multi-walled carbon nanotubes |
3.7 V |
1 mM KCl and 10 mM NaCl (working condition) |
62.5 mV/log [Na+], 59.5 mV/log [K+] |
Radius of curvature 1.5 cm |
- |
No sensitivity degradation by bending radius of 1.5 cm over 60 cycles |
[38] |
Ion |
H+
|
Poly (methylmethacrylate) |
Graphite |
Graphene |
−0.4~0.4 V |
pH 5~8 |
17 mV/pH |
Radius of curvature: 1.2 cm |
0.04 |
No significant change in the electrical response (mobility values remained constant) as a result of bending to radii of curvature as small as 0.7 cm (estimated bending-induced strain: 0.6%) |
[126] |
Ion |
Ca2+, H+
|
PET (polyethylene terephthalate) |
Ag/AgCl reference electrode |
Polyaniline (PANI) |
- |
Typical physiological [Ca2+] variations (e.g., 1 mM to 0.5 mM), pH 4~7 |
32.7 mV/log [Ca2+], 62.5 mV/pH |
- |
- |
- |
[127] |