Skip to main content
. 2019 Mar 19;2019(3):CD011847. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD011847.pub2
Study Reason for exclusion
Abraham 1987 The participants had schizophrenia, but not with a diagnosis of treatment‐resistant.
Abrams 1967 The participants had schizophrenia, but not with a diagnosis of treatment‐resistant.
Agarwal 1985 The participants had schizophrenia, but not with a diagnosis of treatment‐resistant.
Arato 1980 Not RCT
Bagadia 1981 ECT combined with other interventions, but other interventions were not the same between groups: ECT + placebo versus simulated ECT + imipramine
Bagadia 1988 The participants had schizophrenia, but not with a diagnosis of treatment‐resistant.
Baker 1958 The participants had schizophrenia, but not with a diagnosis of treatment‐resistant.
Baker 1960 The participants had schizophrenia, but not with a diagnosis of treatment‐resistant.
Baker 1960a The participants had schizophrenia, but not with a diagnosis of treatment‐resistant.
Bhatia 1987 Not RCT
Brandon 1985 The participants had schizophrenia, but not with a diagnosis of treatment‐resistant.
Brill 1959 Not whole population had schizophrenia or related disorder.
Chatterjee 1980 The participants had schizophrenia, but not with a diagnosis of treatment‐resistant.
ChiCTR‐OPC‐14005339 Not RCT
d'Elia 1970 Not whole population had schizophrenia or related disorder.
Doongaji 1973 The participants had schizophrenia, but not with a diagnosis of treatment‐resistant.
El Islam 1970 The participants had schizophrenia, but not with a diagnosis of treatment‐resistant.
Gan 2017 The participants had schizophrenia, but not with a diagnosis of treatment‐resistant.
Gander 1967 Not whole population had schizophrenia or related disorder.
Gangadhar 2000 The participants had schizophrenia, but not with a diagnosis of treatment‐resistant.
Girish 2003 Not whole population had schizophrenia or related disorder.
Hargreaves 1972 Not whole population had schizophrenia or related disorder.
He 2001 ECT used in both groups: ECT advantage side versus non‐advantage side.
Heath 1964 Not RCT
Janakiramaiah 1981 The participants had schizophrenia, but not with a diagnosis of treatment‐resistant.
Janakiramaiah 1982 The participants had schizophrenia, but not with a diagnosis of treatment‐resistant.
Krystal 1993 Not whole population had schizophrenia or related disorder.
Laurell 1970 Not whole population had schizophrenia or related disorder.
Laurell 1970a Not whole population had schizophrenia or related disorder.
Marjerrison 1975 The participants had schizophrenia, but not with a diagnosis of treatment‐resistant.
Miller 1953 The participants had schizophrenia, but not with a diagnosis of treatment‐resistant.
Naidoo 1956 The participants had schizophrenia, but not with a diagnosis of treatment‐resistant.
Natani 1983 The participants had schizophrenia, but not with a diagnosis of treatment‐resistant.
NCT02159001 ECT used in both groups: ECT treatment right after recruitment versus ECT after 4‐week period.
Rami 2008 The participants had schizophrenia, but not with a diagnosis of treatment‐resistant.
Reichert 1976 Not whole population had schizophrenia or related disorder.
Sarkar 1994 The participants had schizophrenia, but not with a diagnosis of treatment‐resistant.
Small 1968 The participants had schizophrenia, but not with a diagnosis of treatment‐resistant.
Smith 1967 Not RCT
Stenback 1957 ECT used in both groups: usual ECT versus block ECT.
Swoboda 2001 Not RCT
Taylor 1980 The participants had schizophrenia, but not with a diagnosis of treatment‐resistant.
Ukpong 2002 The participants had schizophrenia, but not with a diagnosis of treatment‐resistant.
Ulett 1956 Not whole population had schizophrenia or related disorder.
Ungvari 1981 Language other than English or Chinese
Wessels 1971 The participants had schizophrenia, but not with a diagnosis of treatment‐resistant.
Xue 1985 The participants had schizophrenia, but not with a diagnosis of treatment‐resistant.
Zadeh 2006 Language other than English or Chinese
Zhou 2003 Not RCT

ECT: electroconvulsive therapy; RCT: randomised controlled trial