Table 7.
Diet history interviews | 24-h recalls | Weighed food records | |||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Underreporters n = 158 |
Plausible reporters n = 519 |
Underreporters n = 105 |
Plausible reporters n = 572 |
Underreporters n = 150 |
Plausible reporters n = 527 |
||||||||||
Mean | CI | Mean | CI | Diff.a | Mean | CI | Mean | CI | Diff.a | Mean | CI | Mean | CI | Diff.a | |
(g/day) | (g/day) | (g/day) | (g/day) | (%) | (g/day) | (g/day) | (g/day) | (g/day) | (%) | (g/day) | (g/day) | (g/day) | (g/day) | (%) | |
Bread | 110 | 103; 118 | 169b | 162; 178 | − 35 | 95 | 88; 103 | 141b | 136; 145 | − 32 | 102 | 96; 110 | 138b | 133; 144 | − 26 |
Pastries | 20 | 17; 24 | 42b | 39; 46 | − 53 | 45 | 40; 50 | 70b | 67; 73 | − 36 | 43 | 37; 49 | 73b | 69; 78 | − 41 |
Vegetables, raw | 134 | 119; 151 | 147 | 138; 157 | − 9 | 55 | 47; 66 | 71b | 67; 75 | − 22 | 55 | 47; 65 | 81b | 76; 87 | − 32 |
Vegetables, cooked | 93 | 84; 104 | 114b | 107; 121 | − 18 | 66 | 62; 72 | 70 | 68; 72 | − 5 | 57 | 51; 65 | 80b | 76; 84 | − 28 |
Potatoes | 61 | 55; 67 | 83b | 79; 87 | − 27 | 57 | 51; 64 | 67b | 64; 70 | − 15 | 63 | 55; 72 | 80b | 76; 85 | − 22 |
Fruit | 211 | 186; 244 | 269b | 253; 287 | − 21 | 131 | 113; 151 | 170b | 160; 180 | − 23 | 110 | 94; 129 | 157b | 147; 169 | − 30 |
Nuts/seeds | 1 | 1; 2 | 5b | 4; 7 | − 77 | 1 | 1; 2 | 4b | 3; 4 | − 64 | 1 | 1; 2 | 4b | 3; 5 | − 70 |
Milk/dairy products | 128 | 110; 149 | 230b | 211; 252 | − 45 | 112 | 93; 135 | 180b | 169; 193 | − 38 | 108 | 92; 128 | 175b | 162; 189 | − 38 |
Eggs | 11 | 9; 13 | 14b | 13; 16 | − 24 | 9 | 7; 11 | 12b | 11; 13 | − 24 | 11 | 9; 13 | 14b | 13; 16 | − 26 |
Meat | 31 | 27; 35 | 45b | 42; 49 | − 32 | 44 | 40; 49 | 51 | 49; 53 | − 13 | 35 | 31; 40 | 46b | 43; 49 | − 23 |
Sausages/meat products | 35 | 31; 40 | 60b | 56; 65 | − 42 | 47 | 41; 53 | 65b | 62; 68 | − 28 | 48 | 42; 54 | 69b | 65; 73 | − 31 |
Fish/-products | 17 | 15; 20 | 26b | 24; 28 | − 34 | 16 | 14; 19 | 22b | 21; 23 | − 24 | 15 | 12; 19 | 19 | 18; 22 | − 22 |
Sweets | 11 | 9; 15 | 21b | 19; 24 | − 47 | 8 | 6; 10 | 14b | 13; 15 | − 45 | 7 | 6; 10 | 14b | 13; 16 | − 49 |
Ice cream | 4 | 3; 6 | 9b | 8; 11 | − 54 | 4 | 2; 7 | 8b | 6; 9 | − 50 | 4 | 3; 6 | 8b | 7; 10 | − 52 |
Water | 1309 | 1190; 1434 | 1201 | 1133; 1273 | 9 | 1222 | 1085; 1370 | 963b | 913; 1015 | 27 | 1131 | 1018; 1251 | 921b | 862; 984 | 23 |
Coffee/tea | 427 | 368; 494 | 535b | 496; 578 | − 20 | 406 | 349; 474 | 536b | 506; 565 | − 24 | 314 | 276; 357 | 430b | 403; 458 | − 27 |
Beer | 68 | 48; 105 | 143b | 121; 171 | − 53 | 111 | 81; 155 | 172 | 152; 194 | − 35 | 58 | 39; 84 | 161b | 138; 189 | − 64 |
Wine, sparkling wine | 39 | 27; 61 | 60 | 50; 76 | − 35 | 38 | 28; 52 | 64b | 57; 72 | − 41 | 23 | 16; 33 | 67b | 58; 80 | − 66 |
CI confidence interval calculated with bootstrap method
aDiff. = relative difference between plausible reporters and underreporters (underreporters = 100%)
bMann–Whitney U test between underreporters and plausible reporters p < 0.05