Skip to main content
. 2017 Nov 30;58(1):193–210. doi: 10.1007/s00394-017-1583-z

Table 7.

Food consumption of underreporters and plausible reporters and relative differences between these for each dietary assessment method

Diet history interviews 24-h recalls Weighed food records
Underreporters
n = 158
Plausible reporters
n = 519
Underreporters
n = 105
Plausible reporters
n = 572
Underreporters
n = 150
Plausible reporters
n = 527
Mean CI Mean CI Diff.a Mean CI Mean CI Diff.a Mean CI Mean CI Diff.a
(g/day) (g/day) (g/day) (g/day) (%) (g/day) (g/day) (g/day) (g/day) (%) (g/day) (g/day) (g/day) (g/day) (%)
Bread 110 103; 118 169b 162; 178 − 35 95 88; 103 141b 136; 145 − 32 102 96; 110 138b 133; 144 − 26
Pastries 20 17; 24 42b 39; 46 − 53 45 40; 50 70b 67; 73 − 36 43 37; 49 73b 69; 78 − 41
Vegetables, raw 134 119; 151 147 138; 157 − 9 55 47; 66 71b 67; 75 − 22 55 47; 65 81b 76; 87 − 32
Vegetables, cooked 93 84; 104 114b 107; 121 − 18 66 62; 72 70 68; 72 − 5 57 51; 65 80b 76; 84 − 28
Potatoes 61 55; 67 83b 79; 87 − 27 57 51; 64 67b 64; 70 − 15 63 55; 72 80b 76; 85 − 22
Fruit 211 186; 244 269b 253; 287 − 21 131 113; 151 170b 160; 180 − 23 110 94; 129 157b 147; 169 − 30
Nuts/seeds 1 1; 2 5b 4; 7 − 77 1 1; 2 4b 3; 4 − 64 1 1; 2 4b 3; 5 − 70
Milk/dairy products 128 110; 149 230b 211; 252 − 45 112 93; 135 180b 169; 193 − 38 108 92; 128 175b 162; 189 − 38
Eggs 11 9; 13 14b 13; 16 − 24 9 7; 11 12b 11; 13 − 24 11 9; 13 14b 13; 16 − 26
Meat 31 27; 35 45b 42; 49 − 32 44 40; 49 51 49; 53 − 13 35 31; 40 46b 43; 49 − 23
Sausages/meat products 35 31; 40 60b 56; 65 − 42 47 41; 53 65b 62; 68 − 28 48 42; 54 69b 65; 73 − 31
Fish/-products 17 15; 20 26b 24; 28 − 34 16 14; 19 22b 21; 23 − 24 15 12; 19 19 18; 22 − 22
Sweets 11 9; 15 21b 19; 24 − 47 8 6; 10 14b 13; 15 − 45 7 6; 10 14b 13; 16 − 49
Ice cream 4 3; 6 9b 8; 11 − 54 4 2; 7 8b 6; 9 − 50 4 3; 6 8b 7; 10 − 52
Water 1309 1190; 1434 1201 1133; 1273 9 1222 1085; 1370 963b 913; 1015 27 1131 1018; 1251 921b 862; 984 23
Coffee/tea 427 368; 494 535b 496; 578 − 20 406 349; 474 536b 506; 565 − 24 314 276; 357 430b 403; 458 − 27
Beer 68 48; 105 143b 121; 171 − 53 111 81; 155 172 152; 194 − 35 58 39; 84 161b 138; 189 − 64
Wine, sparkling wine 39 27; 61 60 50; 76 − 35 38 28; 52 64b 57; 72 − 41 23 16; 33 67b 58; 80 − 66

CI confidence interval calculated with bootstrap method

aDiff. = relative difference between plausible reporters and underreporters (underreporters = 100%)

bMann–Whitney U test between underreporters and plausible reporters p < 0.05