Table 1. Main frailty tools used in ACS setting and the prognostic value of frailty assessed by these tests.
Brief description | Pros | Cons | Prognostic implication in ACS | |
Scales based on interview, without objective assessment of physical performance | ||||
FRAIL scale | Five items about fatigue, resistance, ability to walk for one block, concomitant illnesses and loss of weight. Frailty is defined by the presence of 3 or more criteria. | Multidomain evaluation Inclusion of comorbidities |
Time required. Few evidences in ACS. Lacking inclusion of relevant laboratory data. |
Predictor of 6-monthall-cause death.[6] |
Frailty Index | Evaluation based on 32 different variables about symptoms, signs, disabilities, diseases, and laboratory measurements obtaining final point with a threshold of 0.25 defining frailty. | Multidomain evaluation | Time required. | Association with long-term mortality and myocardial Infarction.[7] |
CFS | Nine frailty levels ranging from 1 (very fit) to nine (terminally ill); the degree of frailty can be assessed by simple questions, according to the description encoded for every level. | Ease Convenience Speed practical |
Biased by subjective considerations. Lacking multidomain evaluation. Lacking inclusion of relevant clinical and laboratory data. |
Association with increased risk of in-hospital and 1-month death and increased length of stay.[1],[8]–[11] |
Scales with objective assessment of physical performance | ||||
Fried criteria | Fvie criteria: unintentional weight loss > 4.5 kg in the past year, exhaustion, physical activity, walk time and grip strength (frailty is defined by the presence of three or more criteria). | Strong evidence of frailty identification Multidomain evaluation |
Need of training with a geriatrician Time required. Lacking inclusion of relevant clinical and laboratory data. |
Strong predictor of mortality and myocardial infarction.[12]–[14] |
SHAREFI | Six items: exhaustion, appetite, physical activity, ambulation, resistance and measurement of grip strength. | Multidomain evaluation Speed practical |
Self-reported. Lacking inclusion of relevant clinical and laboratory data. |
Association with early complications and survival.[15] |
EFS | Questions and tasks about nutrition, symptoms, mood and physical performance and it ranges from 0 (not frail) to 17 (very frail). | Multidomain evaluation | Time required. Lacking inclusion of relevant laboratory data. |
Association with length of stay, 1-year mortality and undertreatment.[16],[17] |
Green score | Scale of four items (physical activity, serum albumin, gait speed, grip strength) ranging from 0 to 12. | Multidomain evaluation including laboratory data | Lacking inclusion of clinical data such ad comorbidities. | Predictive value for all-cause death and death/re-infarction.[14] |
Measurements of physical performance | ||||
Grip strength | Assessment of the force of the flexor muscles of the fingers, wrist and forearm by a dynamometer. | Ease Convenience Speed practical |
Lacking multidomain evaluation. Lacking inclusion of relevant clinical and laboratory data. |
Predictive value for cardiac death, all-cause death and hospital admission for heart failure.[18],[19] |
Gait Speed | Evaluation of walking speed with a usual pace for some meters, the length of five to ten meters is the most used. Slow gait speed is defined as a value ≤ 0.8 m/s. | Ease Convenience Speed practical |
Lacking multidomain evaluation. Lacking inclusion of relevant clinical and laboratory data. |
Predictive value for 1-year mortality and hospital Readmission.[20] |
SPPB | Assessment of lower limb function according to three tests: standing balance, usual walking speed and standing chair. The score ranges from 0 (worst performance) to 12 (best performance). Physical performance is considered reduced with a SPPB score ≤ 9. | Multidomain evaluation of physical performance | Need of training with geriatrician. Lacking inclusion of relevant clinical and laboratory data. |
Ongoing study about its usefulness in ACSpatients.[25] |
ACS: acute coronary syndrome; CFS: clinical frailty scale; EFS: Edmonton frail scale; SHARE-FI: Survey of Health, Ageing and Retirement in Europe Frailty Instrument; SPPB: short physical performance battery.