Skip to main content
. 2019 Mar 19;10:229. doi: 10.3389/fneur.2019.00229
Author(s) and year of publication Follow-up interval (months) Number of patients/Number or controls Clinical assessment batteries/Functional rating scales Imaging data Main study findings
IMAGING STUDIES
Floeter et al. (15) 6–18 28/28 ALSFRS-R, letter fluency, FBI, MMSE DWI, structural (T2) - progression and propagation detected (DTI measures) over 6 months - DTI measures correlated with ALSFRS-R, King's stage and cognitive measures
Kassubek et al. (16) 6 67/31 ALSFRS-R DTI - progression detected at group level and 27% of individual patients (DTI measures) - FA correlated with ALSFRS-R
Stampfli et al. (17) 3–6 21/13 ALSFRS-R T1, DWI -progression detected (FD values)
Baldaranov et al. (18) 26 6/6 ALSFRS-R DTI -progression detected (FA, AD/RD values) and correlated with progression on ALSFRS-R
Bede et al., 2017 (14) 4 32/69 ALSFRS-R structural,DTI -progression detected (GM)
de Albuquerque et al. (19) 8 27/27 ALSFRS-R, UMN scale structural (T1, T2) - progression detected (AD, MD) - correlation with ALSFRS-R change
Menke et al. (20) 24 16/0 ALSFRS-R, UMN score T1, DTI, rs-Fmri - progression detected - correlation with ALSFRS-R decline
Simon et al. (21) 3–6 21/13 ALSFRS-R, MRCSS-LL, MUNE DTI, structural (T1) - progression detected (FA values) - correlations with ALSFRS-R change, MUNE, functional disability and strength
Floeter et al. (22) 6 49/28 ALSFRS-R, FBI, MDRS-2, letter fluency, MMSE, D-KEFS structural (T1) -progression detected (ventricular volume)
Schulthess et al. (23) 6 135/56 ALSFRS-R rs-Fmri, DTI - progression detected (functional connectivity) - correlation with physical disability
McMillan et al. (24) 12 20/25 neuropsychology structural (T1) -hypermethylation protective against progression, correlation with protection of some components of neuropsychological assessment
Steinbach et al. (25) 3 16/16 ALSFRS-R, neuropsychology DTI -progression detected
Westeneng et al. (26) 5.5 112/60 ALSFRS-R structural (T1) - progression detected (volume measures) - correlation with ALSFRS-R
Menke et al. (4) 6 60/36 ALSFRS-R, ACE-R structural (T1), DTI -progression detected (GM)
Schuster et al. (27) 3–15 77/60 ALSFRS-R structural (T1) -progression detected (cortical thickness)
Stoppel et al. (28) 3 40/42 ALSFRS-R, MRC, neuropsychology structural, Fmri - progression detected - correlation with ALSFRS-R and MRC
Verstraete et al. (29) 5.5 24/19 ALSFRS-R DTI, structural (T1) - no progression detected - propagation detected
Ignjatovic et al. (30) 6 46/26 ALSFRS-R structural (T1, T2, FLAIR) -progression detected (hypointensities in PGGM)
Kwan et al. (31) 1.26–2.08 years 45/19 ALSFRS-R, finger tapping T1, DTI -progression detected (cortical thickness, GM volume)
Keil et al. (32) 6 24/24 ALSFRS-R, SF36, FAB, MMSE DTI, structural (T1, T2) - progression detected (FA values) - correlations with ALSFRS-R, physical and executive function
Menke et al. (33) 6 24/0 ALSFRS-R DTI -progression detected (AD)
Ichikawa et al. (34) NA 6/NA NA NA -progression detected, correlated to neuropsychology assessment
van der Graaff et al. (35) NA 48/12 ALSFRS-R, finger tapping DWI -progression detected
Zhang et al. (36) 8 17/19 ALSFRS-R structural (T1), DTI - progression detected (FA)
Agosta et al. (37) 9 16/10 ALSFRS structural (T1) - progression detected (GM)
Agosta et al. (38) 9 17/20 ALSFRS DWI, structural - progression detected (cord area, cord average FA)
Avants et al. (39) 5.3 4/4 0 structural (T1) - progression detected (cortical atrophy)
Lule et al. (40) 6 25/15 ALSFRS-R Fmri, structural (T1) - progression detected (activity)
Unrath et al. (41) 6 11/0 ALSFRS MRS, T1 - progression detected (NAA, NAA/Cr+Cho)
Suhy et al. (42) Every 3 months 28/12 0 MRS, T1, T2 - progression detected (NAA, Cr, Cho)
Block et al. (43) 24 33/20 0 MRS - progression detected
Irwin et al. (44) 143/0 MMSE, LGVF structural VBM - no progression on MRI reported
Kolind et al. (45) 42 30/12 ALSFRS-R, ACE, mcDESPOT - progression detected in PLS only
Verstraete et al. (46) 6 45/25 ALSFRS-R structural (T1) - no progression reported
Blain et al. (47) 6–12 23/25 ALSFRS-R, ALSS structural (T2), DWI - no significant progression detected (DTI measures)
Rule et al. (48) 3–12 45/17 0 MRS, structural (T1, T2) - no clear pattern of progressive change over time (NAA rations)
Author(s) and year of publication Follow-up interval (months) Total number of patients/Total number of controls Neurophysiology modality Target muscle Key study findings
NEUROPHYSIOLOGY STUDIES
Escorcio-Bezerra et al. (49) 4.3 21/21 MUNIX tibialis anterior (TA), abductor pollicis brevis (APB) and abductor digiti minimi (ADM) muscles - progression detected (mean MUNIX)
de Carvalho et al. (50) 3–6 73/37 FPs, MUPs, fibs-sw, jitter- MU physiology tibialis anterior - progression detected
Boekestein et al. (51) 8 18/24 MUNIX, HD-MUNE, CMAP, MUSIX thenar - progression detected (MUNE, MUNIX)
Cheah et al. (52) 3 37/0 CMAP, axonal excitability abductor pollicis brevis - progression detected (CMAP)
Ahn et al. (53) NA 135/NA NA NA - asymmetric progression (MUNE)
Cheah et al. (54) 3 58/NA NI, CMAP abductor digiti minimi and ulnar nerve - progression detected (NI)
de Carvalho et al. (55) 6 28/0 NI, CMAP, MUNE abductor digiti minimi muscles - progression detected (CSP)
Neuwirth et al. (56) 15 7/8 MUNIX, CMAP, abductor pollicis brevis (APB), abductor digiti minimi (ADM), abductor halluces brevis (AHB), extensor digitorum brevis (EDB) - progression detected (MUNIX)
Floyd et al. (57) 18 60/33 TMS, CMCT, MEP abductor digiti minimi (ADM) and tibialis anterior (TA) -linear progression detected (TMS threshold, CMCT, TMS amplitude corrected)
Gooch et al. (58) NA 64/NA-1 TMS, MUNE, NA -progression detected (MUNE)
Liu et al. (59) 12 112/12 MUNE, CMAP Abductor pollicis brevis (APB) and abductor digiti quinti (ADQ) - progression detected (MUNE), correlated to ALSFRS descent
Albrecht et al. (60) 11.5 10/25 MUNE, S-MUAP extensor digitorum brevis - progression detected (MUNE)
Wang et al. (61) 12 20/70 MUNE, SMUP, CMAP, MU loss thenar - progression detected - (Thenar MUNE, CMAP)
Chan et al. (62) 24 NA motor units thenar - progression detected
Felice et al. (63) 12 NA MUNE thenar - progression detected (MUNE)
Yuen et al. (64) 6 NA CMAP, MUNE abductor digiti minimi - progression detected (MUNE, fiber density)
Vucic et al. (65) 7–100 days 25/30, 35 cortical and axonal excitability- MEP, CMAP- TMS abductor pollicus brevis - aim to determine effect of riluzole
Aggarwal et al. (66) 36 31/57 MUNE tibialis anterior, abductor pollicis brevis (APB), deltoid, and first dorsal interosseous muscles - no progression reported
Arasaki et al. (67) NA NA MUNE, extensor digitorum brevis (EDB) - no progression reported
de Carvalho et al. (68) 11.6 NA CMAP, MEP, TMS NA - no progression detected
Swash et al. (69) NA 14/NA single fiber EMG NA - no definite progression detected