Skip to main content
. 2019 Mar 26;2019(3):CD009261. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD009261.pub4
Study Reason for exclusion
Al‐Inany 2002 Wrong intervention
Albert 2012 No acute wounds were included.
Anderson 2014 Feasibility study. Predefined criteria used to assess feasibility included: recruitment (> 75% participation); loss to follow‐up (< 10%); intervention fidelity (= 95%); and interrater reliability (kappa = 0.8). Assessment of clinical outcomes was not planned or conducted.
Banasiewicz 2013 Included infected wounds
Bondokji 2011 Prospective cohort study
Braakenburg 2006 Chronic and acute wounds were reported together, and further information was not available.
Chiang 2017 Open wounds
Chio 2010 Skin graft study
Dorafshar 2012 The study used NPWT to treat existing non‐healing skin graft wounds.
Eisenhardt 2012 Skin graft study; no inclusion of wounds healing by primary closure
Grauhan 2013 Quasi‐randomised study: "A total of 156 patients were enrolled and allocated to 2 study groups, alternating according to the time of operation"
Hu 2009 Acute, subacute, and chronic wounds were included. Acute wounds were defined as those that had been "open" for less than 1 week.
Johannesson 2008 The intervention dressing was not a continuous negative pressure device.
Kim 2007 The study was not a randomised controlled trial.
Li 2016 Quasi‐randomisation (by odd and even numbers)
Llanos 2006 Skin graft study
Moisidis 2004 Skin graft study; no inclusion of wounds healing by primary closure
Mouës 2004 No inclusion of acute wounds
Mouës 2007 No inclusion of acute wounds
Pellino 2014 Non‐randomised study in people with Crohn's disease
Petkar 2012 Skin graft study
Rahmanian‐Schwarz 2012 Included chronic and acute wounds, and these were not separately reported
Visser 2017 The vacuum therapy device was a syringe inserted subcutaneously into the dressing, which was used to create a vacuum. Consequently, it was not a standard, continuous pressure device.
Yu 2017 A drain was left inside the wound, so not strictly a primarily closed wound.

NPWT: negative pressure wound therapy