Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2019 Nov 1.
Published in final edited form as: Res Autism Spectr Disord. 2018 Sep 5;55:50–63. doi: 10.1016/j.rasd.2018.08.003

Table 6.

Association of elevated blood manganese concentrations (BMC) with ASD status among children with different GSTP1 genotypes based on co-dominant and dominant genetic models using conditional logistic regression models including the mixture index of the four heavy metals. (163 matched pairs)

Unadjusteda Adjustedb

Genetic
Model
Higher
BMC
Ref.
BMC
Genotype(
s)
Matched
Odds
Ratio
95% CI
for
MOR
P value
c,d
Matched
Odds
Ratio
95% CI
for
MOR
P value
e,f

Co-
dominan
t
BMC >
12pg/L
v
s.
BMC <
12pg/L
a
t
GSTP1
(Ile/Ile)
2.38 (0.95,
6.00)
0.07 4.58 (1.21,
17.42)
0.03
BMC >
12pg/L
v
s.
BMC <
12pg/L
a
t
GSTP1 (Ile/
Val)
0.69 (0.33,
1.46)
0.34 1.26 (0.32,
5.01)
0.74
BMC >
12pg/L
v
s.
BMC <
12pg/L
a
t
GSTP1
(Val/Val)
0.62 (0.21,
1.85)
0.39 0.26 (0.05,
1.42)
0.12

Domina
nt
BMC >
12pg/L
v
s.
BMC <
12pg/L
a
t
GSTP1
(Val/*)
0.67 (0.36,
1.26)
0.22 0.67 (0.25,
1.83)
0.44
BMC >
12pg/L
v
s.
BMC <
12pg/L
a
t
GSTP1
(Ile/Ile)
2.49 (0.99,
6.25)
0.05 4.27 (1.15,
15.85)
0.03
a

Adjusted for the binary mixture index based on four metals (lead, mercury, cadmium, and arsenic)

b

Adjusted for potential confounders including parental education, place of child’s birth (Kingston parish vs. other parishes), consumption of root vegetables (“yam, sweet potato, or dasheen“), salt water fish, and cakes/buns as well as the binary mixture index based on four metals (lead, mercury, cadmium, and arsenic);

c

For the unadjusted co-dominant model, the interaction term had P = 0.06 and the binary mixture index had MOR=0.56 with (P=0.04);

d

For the unadjusted dominant model, the interaction term had P = 0.01 and the binary mixture index had MOR=0.57 with (P=0.04);8

e

For the adjusted co-dominant model, the interaction term had P = 0.03 and the binary mixture index had MOR=1.18 with (P=0.73);

f

For the adjusted dominant model, the interaction term had P = 0.02 and the binary mixture index had MOR=1.14 with (P=0.78). (In the unadjusted analyses for both co-dominant and dominant models, lower mixture index was significantly associated with ASD, but these findings were not observed in the adjusted models.)

Note: All missing data are the same as those reported in the footnote of Tables 24.