Skip to main content
. 2019 Mar 26;14(3):e0209532. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0209532

Table 12. Pairwise Granger causality tests.

Null Hypothesis: Obs F-Statistic
CEMIC does not Granger Cause GDPC 1073
13.732***
GDPC does not Granger Cause CEMIC 47.520***
AIT does not Granger Cause GDPC 965
16.161***
GDPC does not Granger Cause AIT 4.293***
CSE does not Granger Cause GDPC 961
1.510
GDPC does not Granger Cause CSE 11.346***
CR does not Granger Cause GDPC 1073
21.069***
GDPC does not Granger Cause CR 5.530***
AIT does not Granger Cause CEMIC 965
56.007***
CEMIC does not Granger Cause AIT 6.348***
CSE does not Granger Cause CEMIC 961
133.750***
CEMIC does not Granger Cause CSE 22.872***
CR does not Granger Cause CEMIC 1073
51.272***
CEMIC does not Granger Cause CR 3.889***
CSE does not Granger Cause AIT 863
0.498
AIT does not Granger Cause CSE 3.675***
CR does not Granger Cause AIT 965
4.190***
AIT does not Granger Cause CR 3.319**
CR does not Granger Cause CSE 961
0.009
CSE does not Granger Cause CR 0.929

Source: Computation by authors. The lag length was selected by Schwarz Info criterion.

Note: Please see, Table 2 for the variable’s definition

*** specifies the statistically significant at 1% levels.

** specifies the statistically significant at 5% levels.

* specifies the statistically significant at 10% levels.