Skip to main content
. 2019 Feb 14;122(4):500–508. doi: 10.1016/j.bja.2019.01.009

Table 1.

Summary of Delphi round 2 results, with median and percentage of score ≥7 for each criterion of validity, reliability, feasibility, and patient centredness. CRP, C-reactive protein; SIRS, systemic inflammatory response syndrome; WBC, white blood cell count

Summary of item Validity
Reliability
Feasibility
Patient centredness
Unsure Scores ≥7 (%) Median Unsure Scores ≥7 (%) Median Unsure Scores ≥7 (%) Median Unsure Scores ≥7 (%) Median
1a. Fever 3 78 7 3 68 7 3 98 8 3 66 7
1b. CRP measure 3 42 6 3 27 6 3 73 7 3 24 5
1c. Procalcitonin and other biomarkers 5 26 5 5 18 6 5 42 6 5 16 4
1d. WBC/pattern 4 62 7 4 60 7 4 95 8 4 36 6
1e. Antibiotic use 3 53 7 4 43 6 3 86 8 3 49 6
2a. Respiratory infectious complication 4 86 8 4 71 7 4 85 7 4 81 7
2b. Neurological infectious complication 4 90 8 4 85 8 4 72 7 4 79 8
2c. Urological/genitourinary complication 4 91. 8 4 86 7.5 4 88 8 4 86 8
2d. Clostridium difficile colitis or infection 4 88 8 4 86 8 4 83 8 4 79 8
2e. Endometritis 4 78 7 4 66 7 4 74 7 4 83 7
3. Identification of pathogenic organism from culture 5 86 8 5 81 7 5 88 7 5 54 7
4a. Surgical site infection 5 89 8 5 80 7 5 91 8 5 82 8
4b. Superficial incisional surgical site infection 4 88 8 4 77 7 4 88 8 4 84 8
4c. Deep incisional surgical site infection 4 93 8 4 88 8 4 90 8 4 91 8
4d. Organ/space surgical site infection 4 91 8 4 86 8 4 91 8 4 93 8
5a. Sepsis 4 86 8 4 77 7 4 84 7 4 71 7
5b. Septic shock 4 91 8 4 79 8 4 86 8 4 79 8
5c. SIRS 4 65 7 4 63 7 4 84 7 4 56 7