Small molecules:ACCUMULATION |
In general no antenatal manifestations |
In general normal or subtle abnormalities (except decompensations) |
Free interval. Most are efficiently treatable and can be screened at birth |
In general, with treatment, constant improvement |
1, 29 |
AMINOACID CATABOLISM. Diagnosis on AA chromatography. Postnatal neurodevelopmental disruption. Abnormal synaptic signaling, excitotocity (and other specific mechanisms), connectivity alterations, mostly circuitries involved in executive functions. Under treatment, in general mimicking ADHD and learning disabilities |
Phenylalanine PKU |
Not described Maternal PKU: congenital microcephaly, ventriculomegaly, hypoplastic cerebral white matter, and delay of myelination |
White matter T2 reversible hyperintensities |
- Untreated: profound ID. Neuropsychiatric and behavioral AUTISM-like manifestations - Even under strict diet may still present ADHD, NPSY (anxiety, depression) Learning disabilities |
Stability. NDEV disorder Outcome in long-term treated patients at older ages not reported. Diet discontinuation may produce NDEG in adults/elderly patients |
1 |
Homocysteine Homocystinurias |
Not described in CBS Remethylation defects may present as congenital hydro-cephalus |
- Reversible WM lesions in CBS - Hemorrhagic/ischemic stroke |
- Untreated: ID, NPSY, stroke - Even on strict treatment: ADHD, NPSY (obsessions, depression), Learning disabilities |
Stability. NDEV disorder although unknown evolution in elderly patients |
1 |
Leucine MSUD |
Not described |
WM T2 reversible hyperintensities |
- Untreated: ID, spasticity - Even under strict treatment: ADHD, NPSY, Learning disabilities |
Stability. NDEV disorder although unknown evolution in elderly patients |
1 |
Ammonia, Glutamate, Glutamine (in UCD) |
Not described |
WM T2 reversible hyperintensities |
- Even under strict treatment: ADHD, NPSY, Learning disabilities - Cerebral palsy-like in arginase deficiency and HHH |
Stability. NDEV disorder although unknown evolution in elderly patients |
1 |
ORGANIC ACIDURIAS (OA): Diagnosis on OA/Acylcarnitines (GCMS) Postnatal neurodevelopmental disruption. Neurobiological mechanisms similar to AA accumulation but associated with energy depletion. Classic OA under treatment mimic ADHD and learning disabilities whereas “cerebral” OA mimic cerebral palsy (CP) and some of them produce NDEG. |
Propionic, Methylmalonic, Isovaleric acidurias |
Not described |
WM T2 and basal ganglia hyperintensities that may be reversible |
- Untreated: ID, Cerebral palsy-like (spasticity, movement disorders)- Even under strict treatment: ADHD, NPSY, Learning disabilities, Optic atrophy |
Stability. NDEV disorder although unknown evolution in elderly patients |
1 |
Cerebral organic acidurias (COA):Glutaric type 1 |
Immature gyration pattern Bitemporal (biopercular) hypoplasia |
Macrocephaly Subdural hematoma Basal ganglia lesions WM hyperintensities |
- Acute encephalopathy (first 2 years of life), BG lesions. Dyskinetic CP - Mild forms: motor delay versus normality - Tremor, orofacial dyskinesia in adolescence in previously asymptomatic patients |
- After acute BG injury, very similar to dyskinetic CP of other causes (stability but episodes of exacerbation that may lead to status dystonicus) - Unknown in older patients |
1 |
Other COA: L2 OH glutaric; D2 OH glutaric; DL OH glutaric aciduria* Canavan disease (N-AAA) |
L2OH glutaric: cerebellar hypoplasia N-AAA: Soft, gelatinous WM Loss of myelinated arcuated fibres |
Characteristic white matter and cerebellar involvement, cortical atrophy |
L2OH: Progressive cognitive deterioration in infancy with ataxia, seizures, pyramidal signs. Mild forms may mimic ID D2OH: Severe neonatal encephalopathy (seizures, early death) N-AAA: macrocephaly, early regression, progressive spasticity, optic atrophy, death |
All these diseases evolve towards NDEG, with different degrees of severity and natural history |
1 |
SMALL CARBOHYDRATE MOLECULE ACCUMULATION: diagnosis on plasma and urine biomarkers |
Galactosemias (Galactose, Galactose-1-P Galactitol) |
Not reported |
White matter T2 reversible hyperintensities |
Even on strict diet delayed speech development, verbal dyspraxia, difficulties in spatial orientation and visual per-ception, ID, anxiety, depression. Mimics ID and learning difficulties |
Stability. NDEV disorder although unknown evolution in elderly patients |
1 |
METAL ACCUMULATION: Diagnosis on specific metals, protein carriers, brain MRI features, molecular analysis. Postnatal developmental disruption, mainly motor signs mimicking CP but later on progressive neurodegeneration |
Copper ATP7B transporter |
Not described |
“Eye of the panda” sign (lenfiform nuclei, thalamus, midbrain and pons). Atrophy of cerebral and cerebellar cortex |
Wilson disease: bulbar dysfunction, tremor, rigidity, behavioral, and mood disturbances in 1st decade |
NDEG without treatment |
30 |
Iron: NBIA (PKAN, CoASY, PLA2G6, C19oef12, FAH2, WDR45, ATP13A2, FTL, DCAF17, SCP2, GTPBP2)
|
Not described (every defect has different pathophysiological mechanisms; brain iron accumulation is probably a paraphenomenon) |
T2 pallidum hypointensity, leading to the “eye of the tiger” sign. WM alterations may be also present. Cortical and cerebellum atrophy |
More than 10 genetic recognized conditions so far included in the NBIA syndromes. Some of them mimic NDEV disorders:- INAD due to PLA2G6 and early forms of PKAN mimic CP- BPAN mimic Retts |
NDEG is the natural evolution. No effective treatments so far |
30 |
Manganese SLC30A10 and SLC30A14 transporters |
Not described |
Hyperintense T1, hypointense T2 signals on basal ganglia |
Early dystonia-parkinsonism mimicking dystonic CP; hepatic dysfunction is associated |
NDEG is the natural evolution. But may improve on chelation treatment |
30 |
Small molecules: DEFICIENCIES |
Frequent antenatal manifestations, in particular congenital microcephaly |
Wide variety of findings, from normal to severe alterations |
Most have congenital or very early manifestations, mimicking CP or ID with NPSY signs. Late-onset presentations may occur |
Many of them have a treatment with a variable response depending on the particular defect |
1, 29, 32 |
AMINO ACID DEFECTS: Diagnosis on AAC (B, U, CSF), molecular analysis. Prenatal disruption of crucial neurodevelopmental programs. While BCAA deficiencies produce ID, ASD and the clinical spectrum of the synaptopathies, the other AA defects may cause severe antenatal malformations |
Large neutral AA transporter (SLC7A5) and BCDHK Low BCAA |
Congenital microcephaly may be present with no other alterations in the brain MRI |
Hypomyelination |
Mimicking NDEV disorders, in particular ID with NPSY signs, mostly autism spectrum disorder (ASD) |
NDEV disorder: Stability towards improvement with treatment (BCAA supplementation) |
33, 35 |
Glutamine synthetase Low P glutamine |
Complete agyria, hypomyelination, periventricular cysts, Cerebral atrophy |
The same abnormalities found at early stages |
Severe encephalopathy. Severe epilepsy |
Early death. Severe disease involving crucial biological processes and probably incompatible with life |
37 |
Serine defects 3-PGDH(**) PSAT1, PSP Serine (SL-C1A4) transporter Low P serine |
Lissencephaly, microcephaly in Neu Laxova syndrome (congenital form) HM. Hypoplasic cerebellum CC Absent vs hypoplasia |
Mild forms may display microcephaly and hypomyelination |
- Severe encephalopathy: microcephaly, spastic tetraparesis, cataracts, epilepsy. Mimicking congenital infections - Mild forms: ID and epilepsy |
NDEV disorder: stability towards improvement with L-serine supplementation |
36 |
Asparagine synthetase Low to Nl P asparagine |
Simplified gyri Decreased cerebral volume, congenital microcephaly |
The same abnormalities found at early stages |
Profound developmental delay, early-onset intractable seizures, axial hypotonia with severe appendicular spasticity |
Early death. Severe disease involving crucial biological processes and probably incompatible with life |
38 |
NEUROTRANSMITTER DEFECTS: Monoamines and amino acids that behave as neurotransmitters MONOAMINES: Diagnosis mostly on CSF pterins and NT metabolites. Some BH4 deficiencies and DNAJC12 have high plasma phe levels. Low brain dopamine disrupt neurodevelopmental programs probably at early prenatal stages, symptoms may appear at diverse ages and mimic CP AMINO ACIDS that behave as neurotransmitters: Diagnosis based on P, U, CSF analysis. Molecular analysis. Probably prenatal disruption of neurodevelopmental programs although brain malformations are not common. They present with the clinical spectrum of the synaptopathies and some particular defects as severe global encephalopathies. |
Monoamine synthesis defects: (TH, AADC, DNA-JC12, BH4 deficiencies: GTPCH, SR, DHPR, PTPS) |
No antenatal malformations described. In severe forms congenital microcephaly can be present |
In general normal brain MRI although mild nonspecific findings have been found in some cases. BG calcifications can appear in DHPR |
- Very severe forms may cause congenital microcephaly and may be incompatible with life - Early encephalopathies with hypokinetic-rigid and dystonia mimicking CP - Parkinsonism, - L-Dopa responsive dystonia |
NDEV disorder: Stability towards improvement with treatment (L-Dopa, 50HT and related molecules) |
44 |
Monoamine transport defects: DAT, VMAT2
|
Not described |
In general normal brain MRI |
- DAT may present as a severe dyskinetic CP that evolves towards parkinsonism - VMAT2 presents as dystoniaparkinsonism |
DAT may have a NDEG progression. VMAT2 has a similar outcome and treatment than biogenic amine defects |
44 |
GABA defects SSADH (High P/CSF GABA) GABAT (Low CSF GABA) |
Spongiform leukodystrophy in GABAT |
Pallidum hyperintensity, WM lesions, cerebellar atrophy in SSADH |
- SSADH may present as ID and NPSY signs (ASD and others), epilepsy and ataxia - GABAT Early mortality and profound developmental impairment |
SSADH: Stability although progression of epilepsy has been reported in adults Outcome in patients at older ages not reported |
44 |
Glycine NKH: GCS and lipoate disorders High P/CSF Glycine |
Cerebellar hypoplasia Cysts CC absent vs hypoplasia Diffusion restriction pattern in the brain stem (these diseases are also related to AA accumulation defects) |
WM lesions in particular in lipoate related hyperglycinemias |
- Severe neonatal encephalopathy, epilepsy, hypotonia, spasticity, profound mental retardation - Mild forms: Moderate ID, NPSY signs (ADHD, behavioral problems), seizures, chorea episodes |
Early death in the severe forms Stability in mild forms although no long-term outcomes have been reported |
1 |
GABA, glutamate and glycine receptors and transporters |
Congenital polymicrogyria has been described in glutamatergic NMDA receptors. In G I uta mate transporter (SLC25A22): abnormal gyration. CC hypoplasia and congenital microcephaly |
No specific patterns have been reported |
Diverse signs in the spectrum of the synaptopathies: epilepsy, ID, NPSY problems Glycine receptors and transporters: hyperekplexia Glutamate transporter: severe congenital encephalopathy, epilepsy, severe psychomotor delay |
Severe mutations in the glutamate receptors lead to early death Stability versus improvement with clonazepam in some forms of hyperekplexia |
1, 44 |
AGC1 (SLC25A12) Low CSF NAA, high lactate |
Global hypomyelination (this disease is also an energy defect) |
BG hyperintensity, delayed myelination, reduced NAA in brain MRS, cerebellar atrophy |
Arrested psychomotor development, hypotonia, infantile onset epilepsy |
Severe encephalopathy. Long-term outcome not reported |
1, 44 |
METAL DEFICIENCIES: Diagnosis on specific metals and protein disruption since they present with severe early encephalopath |
Copper (low serum copper and ceruleoplasmin ATP7A) |
Brain vascular tortuosities |
Cephalhematomas, vascular tortuosity |
Menkes disease is a severe early encephalopathy. Seizures, hypotonia, loss of developmental milestones Mild forms (occipital horn syndrome) may present with mild to moderate ID |
Menkes disease is a NDEG disorder |
30 |
AP1S1 (Low serum cerulopasmin and copper) |
Not reported (MEDNIK syndrome is also a trafficking disorder) |
Mild T2 hyperintensity of caudate and putamen, brain atrophy |
Multisystem disease. Dysmorphic features, Ichthyosis, ID, deafness, peripheral neuropathy, hepatopathy |
Liver copper overload treatable by zinc acetate therapy This disease may be progressive, but there are no outcome reports |
43 |
Manganese (Low blood Mn and Zn) SLC39A8
|
Cerebellar atrophy |
Severe atrophy of cerebellar vermis and hemispheres |
Severe encephalopathy, hypotonia, seizures, strabismus, profound ID |
Stability, mild NDEV achievements Progressive cerebellar signs reported in one family (NDEG?) |
41, 42 |
BRAIN ENERGY MOLECULE TRANSPORTER DEFECTS: Diagnosis on B and CSF glucose/lactate/KB. RBC glucose and lactate uptake. Due to the energy characteristics of the prenatal brain and the newborn, these diseases should produce post-natal neurodevel-opmental disruptions. They mimic CP and ID |
GLUT 1 deficiency (low CSF glucose) |
Not reported |
Normal brain MRI. Severe forms may have microcephaly |
- Early infantile severe epilepsy - Motor dysfunction that may be diverse and combined: cerebellar ataxia/dyspraxia, pyramidal signs, dyskinesias, mimicking CP - ID may be associated |
Improvement with ketogenic diet and other anaplerotic treatments (such as triheptanoin) |
62 |
Monocarboxylicacid transporter (lactate, pyruvate, ketone bodies) SLC16A1
|
Not reported |
|
Recurrent attacks of ketoacidosis. Moderate ID in homozygous forms |
Stability of ID although no long-term outcomes reported |
63 |
FATTY ACID TRANSPORTER and SYNTHESIS DEFECTS: Diagnosis on FFA profile, lipidomics, molecular investigations |
DHA transporter: MFSD2A High plasma LPC (Low brain DHA?) |
Cortical malformation, gross hydrocephaly, hugely dilated lateral ventricles cerebellar/brain stem hypoplasia/atrophy |
The same antenatal manifestations, microcephaly |
Severe encephalopathy: developmental delay, hypotonia, hyperreflexia, spastic quadriparesis, seizures |
Lethal microcephaly syndrome |
34 |
FA elongation: ELOVL4 (NL serum FA) |
Not reported |
Cerebellar atrophy |
Severe encephalopathy: Ichthyosis, seizures, ID, spasticity resembling Sjogren Larsson (mimicking CP) Spinocerebellar ataxia. Retinopathy |
NDEG disease Neonatal death reported in a mouse model |
40, 49 |
Fatty aldehyde dehydrogenase (FALDH)
|
Not reported |
Not reported |
Sjogren Larsson syndrome: Congenital pruritic ichthyosis with bilateral spastic paraparesis, dysarthria, mild ID Mimic CP |
Not enough information about outcome |
49 |
ELOVL5 Low serum C20-4, C22-6 |
Not reported |
Cerebellar atrophy |
Spinocerebellar ataxia |
NDEG disease |
49 |
VITAMIN/COFACTOR DEFECTS: Diagnosis on AAC, OAC, folates, B12, molecular investigations1 |
Biotin Biotinidase |
Not reported |
WM and BG abnormalities have been described |
Biotin responsive MCD deficiency Seizures, developmental delay. Hearing loss. Crisis. Optic atrophy |
Early treatment with biotin is very efficient. Stability towards improvement. |
1 |
B12 Cobalamin C |
Congenital hydrocephalus Hypomyelination and ventriculomegaly in HCFC1 |
Similar to antenatal |
Progressive neurological deterioration crisis, abnormal movements, seizures, microcephaly |
HCFC1 may cause early death Other causes: Stability towards improvement |
1 |
Folic acid (FOLR) MTHFR |
Not reported |
Hypomyelination, cerebellar atrophy, microcephaly, enlarged ventricles |
Progressive encephalopathy, seizures, microcephaly, psychiatric disorders |
If treated, stability towards improvement |
1 |
B6 (pyridoxine) Antiquitin PNPO |
May have hypoxicencephalopathy like features. Thin CC |
Subtle, nonspecific findings |
Neonatal pyridoxine-dependent epilepsy Some cases with encephalopathy PLP dependent epilepsy |
Stability towards improvement PNPO has been related to early death |
1 |
Mitochondrial TPP transporter (SLC25A19) Thiamine transporter (SLC19A3) |
SLC25A19: Extreme microcephaly lissencephaly, dysgenesis of the corpus callosum, spinal dysraphic state |
SLC19A3: Basal ganglia necrosis |
SLC25A19: Amish lethal microcephaly: extreme microcephaly SLC19A3: Recurrent BG involvement, thiamine-responsive |
SLC25A19: Early death. One case of long-term survival with profound ID and microcephaly has been reported SLC19A3: may be fully reversible with thiamine (improvement) |
1 |
TPP kinase |
Not reported |
Increased signal intensities in the corticospinal tract at the medulla oblongata, and increased intensities in the dorsal pons. BG necrosis |
Psychomotor retardation, severe encephalopathy, dystonia, ataxia |
Stability after symptom onset although not enough information about outcome has been reported |
1 |
AA: amino acids; AAC: aminoacid chromatography; ADHD; attention deficient hyperactivity disorder; AGC1: aspartate glutamate mitochondrial carrier; AADC: aromatic amino acid decarboxylase; AD: autosomal dominant; AR: autosomal recessive; ASD: autism spectrum disorder; BCDHK: branched chain dehydrogenase kinase; BG: basal ganglia; BPAN: β propeller associated neurodegeneration; CC: corpus callosum; CoASY: coenzyme A synthetase; COA: cerebral organic acidurias; CP: cerebral palsy; CSF: cerebrospinal fluid; DAT: dopamine transporter; DHA: docosahexanoic acid; DHPR: dihydropterine reductase; D-P: dystonia parkinsonism; DNAJC12: chaperone associated with complex assembly, protein folding, and export; DRD: dopa responsive dystonia; ELOV: fatty acid elongase; FA: fatty acid; FOLR: folate receptor, mutations leading to brain folate depletion; GABA: γ-aminobutyric acid; GABAT: GABA transaminase; GCMS: Gas chromatography mass spectrometry; GCS: glycine cleavage system; GTPCH: guanosine triphosphate cyclohydroxilase; HCFO: gene responsible for X-linked cobalamin deficiency; HM: hypomyelination; HVA: homovanillic acid; ID: intellectual disability; INAD: infantile neuroaxonal dystrophy; KB: ketone bodies; LPC: lysophosphatidylcholine; MCD: multiple carboxylase; MHBD:2-methyl-3-Hydroxybutyryl-CoA dehydrogenase; MHPG: 3-Methoxy-4-hydroxyphenylglycol; MSUD: maple syrup urine disease; MTHFR: methylene tetrahydrofolate reductase; NAA:N-acetyl aspartate; NBIA: neurodegeneration with brain iron accumulation; NDEG: neurodegeneration; NDEV: neurodevelopmental; NPSY: neuropsychiatric; OAC: organic acid chromatography; SDE: syndrome; WM: white matter; NL: neu-laxova, severe form of serine synthesis deficiency. NKH: non ketotic hyperglycinemias; OA: organic acid; NR: not reported; OGC: oculogyric crisis; PHE: phenylalanine; PKAN: pantothenate kinase-associated neurodegeneration; P:plasma; PKU: phenylketonuria; PLP: pyridoxal 5'-phosphate; PNPO: pyridox(am)ine 5'-phosphate oxidase; PSAT1: phosphoserine aminotransferase; PSP: phosphoserine phosphatase; PTPS: PVC: paraventricular cysts; PVM: periventricular leucomalacia; RBC: red blood cell; SR: sepiapterine reductase; SSADH: succinyl adenosine dehydrogenase; TH: tyrosine hydroxylase; TPP: thiamine pyrophosphate; U: urine; UCD: urea cycle disorders; VMAT: brain vesicular monoamine transporter 2; WM: white matter; 3-PGDH: 3-Phosphoglycerate Dehydrogenase Deficiency; 5-HIAA: 5-hydroxyindolaceticacid; 5-OH-T5 hydroxytryptophane Important and frequent manifestations and outcome are in bold. (*) SLC25A1 citrate mito carrier. (**) This variation of clinical manifestations may be common in many other disorders. Severe defects affect early developmental stages and behave as brain malformations whereas mild forms may present as “synaptopathies.” |