1. Crystalloid volumes used in included studies.
Study | Timing | Comparator group | Intervention group(s) |
Ali 2003 | Preoperative | RL 2 mL/kg | RL 15 mL/kg |
Amireh 2009 | Preoperative | No crystalloid bolus | RL 10 mL/kg |
Ashok 2017 | Intraoperative | RL 10 mL/kg | RL 30 mL/kg |
Behdad 2011 | Intraoperative | RL 4 mL/kg | RL 10 mL/kg |
Intraoperative | RL 20 mL/kg | ||
Bennett 1999 | Preoperative | NS 1 to 2 mL/kg | NS 15 mL/kg |
Bhukal 2012 | Intraoperative | NS 4 mL/kg | NS 10 mL/kg |
Chaudhary 2008 | Preoperative | RL 2 mL/kg | RL 12 mL/kg |
Chauhan 2013 | Preoperative | RL 10 mL/kg | RL 30 mL/kg |
Chohedri 2006 | Preoperative | NS 2 mL/kg | NS 20 mL/kg |
Cook 1990 | Preoperative | No crystalloid bolus | RL 20 mL/kg |
Preoperative | RL 20 mL/kg with 1 g/kg dextrose | ||
Dagher 2009 | Preoperative | RL 10 mL/kg | RL 30 mL/kg |
Egeli 2004 | Postoperative | No crystalloid bolus | D5RL 60 to 120 mL/hour |
Elgueta 2013 | Intraoperative | RL 10 mL/kg/hour | RL 30 mL/kg/hour |
Elhakim 1998 | Intraoperative | No crystalloid bolus | RL 1000 mL |
Goodarzi 2006 | Intraoperative | RL 10 mL/kg/hour | RL 30 mL/kg/hour |
Gwak 2007 | Intraoperative | RL 6 mL/kg/hour | RL 18 mL/kg/hour |
Hashish 2007 | Preoperative | RL 10 mL/kg | RL 30 mL/kg |
Heidari 2012 | Preoperative | No crystalloid bolus | RL 10 mL/kg |
Heshmati 2004 | Intraoperative | No crystalloid bolus | RL 4 mL/kg/hour |
Holte 2004 | Preoperative | RL 15 mL/kg | RL 40 mL/kg |
Ismail 2017 | Intraoperative | RL 10 mL/kg | RL 30 mL/kg |
Keane 1986 | Mixed | No crystalloid bolus | Intraoperative RL 1000 mL then postoperative 1000 mL D5W |
Lambert 2009 | Preoperative | No crystalloid bolus | RL 900 to 1000 mL |
Lee 2009 | Preoperative | RL 5 mL/kg/hour | RL 30 mL/kg/hour |
Magner 2004 | Preoperative | RL 10 mL/kg | RL 30 mL/kg |
Maharaj 2005 | Preoperative | RL 2 mL/kg per hour fasted | RL 3 mL/kg per house fasted |
McCaul 2003 | Intraoperative | No crystalloid bolus | RL 1.5 mL/kg per hour fasted |
Intraoperative | D5RL 1.5 mL/kg per hour fasted | ||
Monti 1999 | Preoperative | No crystalloid bolus | RL 1000 mL |
Murshed 2012 | Preoperative | RL 1.5 mL/kg per hour fasted | RL 15 mL/kg |
Najafianaraki 2010 | Preoperative | RL 2 mL/kg per hour fasted | RL 2 mL/kg per hour fasted then RL 10 mL/kg |
Onyando 2014 | Preoperative | No crystalloid bolus | RL "maintenance" rate per hour fasted (maximum 1000 mL) |
Ooi 1992 | Preoperative | No crystalloid bolus | 20 mL/kg 4% dextrose/0.18% saline solution |
Paganelli 2008 | Intraoperative | NS 10 mL/kg/hour | NS 1000 mL bolus then 10 mL/kg/hour |
Sharma 2010 | Preoperative | RL 10 mL/kg | RL 20 mL/kg |
Preoperative | RL 30 mL/kg | ||
Shin 2007 | Preoperative | RL 2 mL/kg | RL 20 mL/kg |
Singh 2013 | Preoperative | No crystalloid bolus | RL 30 mL/kg |
Soleimani 2018 | Preoperative | NS 1.5 mL/kg/hour | NS 1.5 mL/kg/hour then RL 5 mL/kg |
Intraoperative | NS 1.5 mL/kg/hour then RL 5 mL/kg | ||
Spencer 1988 | Intraoperative | No crystalloid bolus | RL 1000 mL |
Yilmaz 2014 | Intraoperative | NS 10 mL/kg/hour | NS 20 mL/kg/hour |
Yogendran 1995 | Preoperative | Plasmalyte 2 mL/kg | Plasmalyte 20 mL/kg |
Yoon 2008 | Intraoperative | RL 2 mL/kg | RL 18 mL/kg |
D5RL: dextrose 5% in Ringer's Lactate; D5W: dextrose 5% in water, NS: normal saline, RL: Ringer's Lactate