Skip to main content
. 2019 Apr 1;2019(4):CD001534. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD001534.pub4
Study Reason for exclusion
Bergstrom 1968 Short duration: antibiotic treatment after randomisation was only 50 days
Bose 1974 Wrong intervention: acute treatment of two types of antibiotics followed by nitrofurantoin prophylaxis i.e. no prophylactic control group
Clemente 1994 Wrong intervention: pidotimod, an immunostimulant agent, plus antibiotics versus placebo for 60 days
Craig 2002 Wrong population: > 50% of children had VUR
Espino Hernandez 2012 Wrong population: > 50% of children had VUR
Feldman 1975 Short duration: 4 week "short term" TMP/SMX versus SMX
Fennell 1980 Short duration: 10 day treatment of ampicillin versus cotrimoxazole versus cephalexin
Fischbach 1989 Short duration: acute treatment for 2 weeks
Garin 2006 Wrong population: 52% of participants had VUR, our inclusion criteria is < 50% with VUR
Habeeb Abid 2015 Wrong population: > 50% children had VUR
Hari 2015 Wrong population: > 50% children had VUR
Lee 2007a Wrong population: all children had VUR
Lindberg 1978 Short duration: acute treatment study; treatment consisted of nitrofurantoin for 10 days, only received 6 month treatment if they had 2 recurrences
Madsen 1973 Wrong population/short duration: cotrimoxazole versus methacycline for 14 days in mostly adults
Marild 2009 Short duration: acute treatment study
Mohseni 2013 Wrong population: > 50% of children had VUR
Montini 2007 Short duration: acute treatment study
Pennesi 2008 Wrong population: all children have VUR
Pisani 1982 Short duration: acute treatment for 10 days
Ray 1970 Wrong population: > 50% of participants had neurogenic/renal abnormalities
RIVUR 2008 Wrong population: > 50% of participants had VUR
Roussey‐Kesler 2008 Wrong population: all children have VUR
Sanchez‐Bayle 1983 Wrong population: > 50% of participants had VUR
Swedish Reflux 2010 Wrong population: > 50% of participants had VUR
Zegers 2011 Wrong population: children with urological and urological abnormality, spina bifida

SMX ‐ sulphamethoxazole; TMP ‐ trimethoprim; VUR ‐ vesicoureteric reflux