Skip to main content
. 2019 Apr 4;2019(4):CD010880. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD010880.pub2
Mental state: 1d. Specific: various aspects – mean endpoint score (various subscales) (skewed data)
Study Intervention Mean SD N
Aggressiveness (Colorado Client Assessment Record (CCAR), high = greater severity) – medium term
Reynolds 2004 Peer support 1.20 0.63 8
Reynolds 2004 Standard care 1.10 0.32 11
Anxiety (CCAR, high = greater severity) – medium term
Reynolds 2004 Peer support 3.33 1.73 8
Reynolds 2004 Standard care 3.00 1.88 11
Attention problem (CCAR, high = greater severity) – medium term
Reynolds 2004 Peer support 1.89 1.62 8
Reynolds 2004 Standard care 2.50 1.84 11
Behavioural and cognitive symptom (Instrument to Measure Self‐Management (IMSM), high = greater frequency) – medium term
Goldberg 2013 Peer support 1.9 1.0 28
Goldberg 2013 Standard care 1.8 1.2 29
Cognitive problem (CCAR, high = greater severity) – medium term
Reynolds 2004 Peer support 1.89 1.45 8
Reynolds 2004 Standard care 1.80 1.32 11
Depression (Behaviour and Symptom Identification Scale (BASIS‐24), high= greater severity) – medium term
Eisen 2012 peer support 1.3 0.9 74
Eisen 2012 standard care 1.21 0.87 84
Depression (CCAR, high = greater severity) – medium term
Reynolds 2004 peer support 2.44 1.42 8
Reynolds 2004 standard care 3.4 1.43 11
Emotional lability (BASIS‐24, high = greater severity) – medium term
Eisen 2012 Peer support 1.32 1.06 74
Eisen 2012 Standard care 1.49 0.95 84
Emotional withdrawal (CCAR, high = greater severity) – medium term
Reynolds 2004 Peer support 2.56 1.94 8
Reynolds 2004 Standard care 2.20 1.75 11
Family problems (CCAR, high = greater severity) – medium term
Reynolds 2004 Peer support 1.67 1.41 8
Reynolds 2004 Standard care 1.40 0.97 11
Hyperaffect (CCAR, high = greater severity) – medium term
Reynolds 2004 Peer support 1.56 1.33 8
Reynolds 2004 Standard care 1.40 0.70 11
Interpersonal relationship (BASIS‐24, high = greater severity) –medium term
Eisen 2012 peer support 1.28 0.76 74
Eisen 2012 standard care 1.26 0.85 84
Interpersonal problems (CCAR, high = greater severity) – medium term
Reynolds 2004 peer support 2.78 1.3 8
Reynolds 2004 standard care 2.5 1.43 11
Loneliness (Loneliness Scale, high = greater loneliness) – medium term
Van Gestel‐Timmermans 2012 Peer support 5.45 3.87 125
Van Gestel‐Timmermans 2012 Standard care 6.49 3.68 102
Physical activity (IMSM, high = greater frequency) – medium term
Goldberg 2013 Peer support 3.2 1.2 28
Goldberg 2013 Standard care 2.2 1.4 29
Psychotic symptoms (BASIS‐24, high = greater severity) – medium term
Eisen 2012 peer support 0.58 0.87 74
Eisen 2012 standard care 0.66 0.87 84
Positive symptoms (BSI, high = greater severity) – medium term
Cook 2012b peer support 19.52 13.74 224
Cook 2012b standard care 21.38 13.68 234
Positive symptom (BSI, high = greater severity) – long term
Cook 2012b peer support 12.2 outlier 220
Cook 2012b standard care 12.65 15 228
Resistiveness (CCAR, high = greater severity) – medium term
Reynolds 2004 Peer support 1.67 1.41 8
Reynolds 2004 Standard care 1.40 0.84 11
Self‐harm (BASIS‐24, high = greater severity) ‐– medium term
Eisen 2012 Peer support 0.18 0.50 74
Eisen 2012 Standard care 0.18 0.46 84
Suicide feelings (CCAR, high = greater severity) – medium term
Reynolds 2004 Peer support 2.22 2.44 8
Reynolds 2004 Standard care 1.70 1.06 11
Thought process difficulties (CCAR, high = greater severity) – medium term
Reynolds 2004 peer support 2.56 2 8
Reynolds 2004 standard care 2.1 1.91 11