4. Participates in group problem-solving process (IPS).
Pre-Emergent	Emerging (1 point)	Acquiring (2 points)	Mastering (3 points)
Has not achieved the Emerging level. Does not provide input during group sessions. ThinkShare entries do not reflect consideration of peer ideas or approaches.	ThinkShare entries reference peer ideas or approaches. Participates in group problem-solving process (e.g., offers ideas or explanations, serves as a scribe, suggests resources).	ThinkShare entries reference how the student used peer ideas to aid his/her approach to cases. Or student suggests constructive ideas that promote or redirect group discussion, evaluates resources, or begins to take the lead in group discussions.	ThinkShare entries or contributions during group sessions model problem-solving in a clear, thorough, organized, and thoughtful manner. Or during group sessions, consistently suggests ideas that help lead or redirect group discussion without dominating.

CLERKSHIP LEVEL (for reference; not expected of pre-clerkship students): Participates in problem-solving as a member of the clinical team. Presents ideas in a thoughtful, organized, clear manner.