9. Acknowledges differences of opinion and perspective among group members (PRO). This scale is based on the quality of performance.
Pre-Emergent	Emerging (1 point)	Acquiring (2 points)	Mastering (3 points)
Has not achieved the Emerging level.	Acknowledges differences of opinion or perspective among group members, but with some difficulty.	Articulates differences of opinion or perspective among group members.	Models respectful behaviors for others or actively assists group in reconciling differences of opinion or perspective.
CLERKSHIP LEVEL (for reference; not expected of pre-clerkship students): Always conducts himself/herself in manner that respects all members of clinical team and patients.