Table I:
Learning Objective |
Key Concepts | Skill building activities |
---|---|---|
Application of genomic technology concepts | (1) HGVS variant nomenclature standards | - Look up variants in reference databases, considering different naming conventions and/or legacy names when applicable - Use HGVS nomenclature to properly describe variants in written summaries and reports |
(2) Benefits and limitations of genomic tests and technologies | - Practice examples illustrating these points, and discuss with supervisor | |
(3) Technical aspects of variant calling, filtering, and prioritization steps of genomic sequencing analyses | - Utilize a patient case to demonstrate how and when filtration criteria are applied | |
Critical use of genomics resources | (1) Critical use of databases and tools | - Look up variants in reference databases, including examples that demonstrate limitations of such databases and tools, discuss examples with supervisor |
(2) Critical evaluation of relevant medical literature | - Practice examples and discussion with supervisor - Read and assess biomedical literature relevant to patient variants |
|
(3) Identification and assessment of relevant evidence supporting/refuting variant pathogenicity | - Practice examples and discussion with supervisor - Identify and discuss key supporting/refuting evidence from both literature and database resources |
|
Assessment of phenotypes | (1) Construction of a comprehensive disease narrative for a patient | - Review patient medical records and family history - Summarize patient narrative for supervisor |
(2) Identification of primary and secondary clinical features | - Practice examples and discussion with supervisor - Translate relevant clinical features to HPO terms using HPO browser |
|
(3) Identification of pertinent positive findings, and differentiation between pertinent negative findings and the absence of data | - Practice examples and discussion with supervisor - Translate relevant clinical features to HPO terms using HPO browser |
|
Evaluation of gene-disease associations | (1) Weighting of a combination of different data types | - Read seminal readings on gene-level evidence evaluation (e.g. MacArthur et al., 2014; Strande et al., 2017) |
(2) Variants in the same gene can cause different diseases, and the same disease may present on a phenotypic spectrum | - Practice examples and discussion with supervisor | |
(3) Evaluation of genes for their potential role in human disease, and assessment of the strength of available evidence | - Perform and write a literature review of gene-level evidence for a given gene, applying the conceptual framework, starting with selected training examples - Evaluate gene-disease associations and assign strength of evidence from patient cases |
|
Review and classification of variants | (1) Variant interpretation uses a framework of explicit rules (e.g. ACMG/AMP guidelines) | - Read seminal papers on ACMG/AMP guidelines (Richards et al., 2015; Amendola et al., 2016; Biesecker & Harrison, 2018) |
(2) Variants must be interpreted within patient and disease context | - Practice variant assessment and assign classifications of example variants - Perform variant assessment and assign classification of patient variants - Summarize variant information in written and verbal formats |
|
(3) Different guidelines are applicable to different types of variants | - Practice assigning guidelines for example variants, and discuss with supervisor - Assess and classify an entire set of prioritized patient variants for at least one patient, under supervision and write up or present results |
|
Standards and diversity in reporting criteria | (1) Reportability standards and deliverables vary according to test type, analysis setting, and finding type (primary, secondary, incidental) | - Read a variety of example reports |
(2) Communicate complex variant interpretation decisions, and underlying evidence, to genetics professionals | - Practice examples and discussion with supervisor - Write variant summaries for review by supervisor - Discuss variant summaries with rotation team members |
|
(3) Summarize complex genetics concepts to patients and study participants | - Report variants to genetics professionals and patients and/or study participants, under supervisor guidance |