Skip to main content
. 2016 Oct 11;2016(10):CD012371. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD012371
Study Reason for exclusion
Berger 2007 Not screened for trauma
Bolton 2007 Screened for depression but not trauma
Burke 1988 Not randomised; matched control
Catani 2009 All participants had to meet criteria for PTSD to be included in this study; therefore, it was reviewed in Gillies 2012
Chen 2014 All participants had scores > 18 on the CRIES‐13, which was cited as 81% sensitivity and 77% specificity for PTSD ‐ to be reviewed in the update of Gillies 2012
Cohen 2004 All participants had to meet criteria for PTSD to be included in this study; therefore, it was reviewed in Gillies 2012
Cooley‐Strickland 2011 Exposure to trauma was not an inclusion criterion
Dybdahl 2001 Intervention for mothers only
Ehntholt 2005 Not randomised
Ensink 2004 No data reported, and study authors could not be contacted
Ertl 2011 All participants had to meet criteria for PTSD to be included in this study; therefore, it was reviewed in Gillies 2012
Gelkopf 2009 Exposure to trauma was not an inclusion criterion
Gellman 2001 Not randomised; matched control
Goenjian 1997 Pre‐post study
Graham‐Bermann 2013 Partcipants were sequentially allocated to groups
Hardin 2002 Not screened for trauma
Jacob 2014 All participants had to meet criteria for PTSD; therefore, this study will be reviewed in the update of Gillies 2012
Jeffres 2004 Not randomised
Jensen 2014 Included participants had scores ≥ 15 on the Child PTSD Symptom Scale, which is considered diagnostic of PTSD ‐ to be included in the update of Gillies 2012
Jordans 2010 Exposure to trauma was not an inclusion criterion
Kassam‐Adams 2011 Randomised trial of stepped care versus usual care
Kataoka 2003 Data for randomised controls not reported and could not be obtained
Kenardy 2008 Case control study
King 2000 All participants had to be diagnosed with PTSD to be included in this study; therefore, it was reviewed in Gillies 2012
Krueger 2013 Children were alternately allocated to trauma‐focused interpersonal therapy or CBT
Lyshak‐Stelzer 2007 Interim analysis of the data (30/55 not LTFU – 86 randomised in total with 31 LTFU at this report)
McWhirter 2011 Did not report included outcomes
Murray 2015 Mean baseline trauma symptom item scores (PTSD‐RI 38‐item trauma symptom scale) were 1.88 in the TF‐CBT group and 1.75 in the TAU group ‐ to be reviewed in the update of Gillies 2012
Pfeffer 2002 Families were alternately allocated; loss to follow‐up was 75% in the no treatment group
Phipps 2012 Intervention was not a psychological therapy
Rosner 2014 Ongoing study of cognitive processing therapy versus usual care for treatment of adolescents and young adults with PTSD following abuse. To be reviewed in the update of Gillies 2012
Rubin 2001 Not screened for trauma
Ruf 2010 All participants had to meet criteria for PTSD to be included in this study; therefore, it was reviewed in Gillies 2012
Ruf 2012 Study of Lifeline‐NET, short‐term narrative exposure therapy for refugees and asylum Seekers aged 16 to 60 years with PTSD. This will be reviewed in the update of Gillies 2012
Saxe 2012 Only 1 of 10 participants in the usual care group were followed up
Schaal 2009 Average age of participants was 19 years
Schauer 2008 All participants had to meet criteria for PTSD to be included in this study; therefore, it was reviewed in Gillies 2012
Scheeringa 2011 Less than 50% of the intervention group were randomised
Shelby 1995 No comparison group
Shooshtary 2008 Not randomised
Soltanifar 2012 Study of attachment‐based play therapy compared to supportive therapy for children with developmental trauma disorder. This will be reviewed in the update of Gillies 2012
Stronach 2012 Both interventions working with mother, although directed at the parent/child interaction
Thabet 2005 Not randomised
Wang 2011 Not screened for trauma; case control study
Wolmer 2011a Not randomised
Wolmer 2011b Not randomised

LTFU: Loss to follow‐up