Skip to main content
. 2016 Jul 6;2016(7):CD009323. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD009323.pub3
Study Reason for exclusion
Abdalla 2003 Insufficient diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Adisa 2014 No separate data available for pancreatic or periampullary cancers
Alexakis 2015 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Altieri 1982 Wrong target condition
Andren‐Sandberg 1998 Includes participants who were considered to be unresectable by CT scan
Arnold 2001 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Atanov 1972 No separate data available for pancreatic or periampullary cancers
Awad 1997 Includes participants who were considered to be unresectable by CT scan
Baghbanian 2013 Not clear whether histopathological confirmation of metastasis was obtained
Baghbanian 2014 Not clear whether histopathological confirmation of metastasis was obtained
Balcom 2000 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Barabino 2011 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Barrat 1998 No separate data available for pancreatic or periampullary cancers
Barreiro 2002 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Barthet 2007 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Baumgarten 1984 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Beger 1997 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Belagyi 2000 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Bemelman 1995 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Bohmig 2001 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Borbath 2005 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Boselli 2000 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Bottger 1998 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Boyce 1992 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Caldironi 1996 The proportion of participants who were considered to be resectable after CT scan is not known
Callery 1997 No separate data available for pancreatic or periampullary carcinoma
Callery 2009 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Camacho 2005 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Carmichael 1995 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Carpenter 1996 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Catheline 1998 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Catheline 1999 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Chambon 1995 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Champault 1996 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Champault 1997 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Charukhchyan 1998 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Cipollone 2012 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Conlon 1997 The number of participants with pancreatic or periampullary cancers is not stated
Conlon 1999 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Conlon 2002 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Connor 2004 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Croome 2009 Insufficient diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Croome 2010 Insufficient diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Cuesta 1993 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Cuschieri 1978 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Cuschieri 1988 The proportion of participants who were considered to be resectable after CT scan is not known
D'Angelica 2003 Wrong target condition
Dadan 1980 Insufficient diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Doran 2004 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Doucas 2007 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Duffy 2008 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Durup Scheel‐Hincke 1999 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Eigler 1999 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Ellsmere 2005 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Enestvedt 2008 Includes participants who were considered to be unresectable by CT scan
Fernandez‐del Castillo 1994 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Fernandez‐del Castillo 1998 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Ferrone 2006 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Feussner 2000 No separate data available for pancreatic or periampullary cancer
Fevery 1985 No separate data available for pancreatic or periampullary cancer
Fockens 1993 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Friess 1997 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Friess 1998 No separate data available for pancreatic or periampullary cancer
Fristrup 2006 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Fukumoto 1989 No separate data available for pancreatic or periampullary cancer
Garcea 2012 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Garofalo 2009 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Gouma 1996 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Gouma 1999 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Gouma 2002 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Hann 1997 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Hashimoto 2015 In this study, all 11 participants who underwent diagnostic laparoscopy and laparotomy had resectable pancreatic cancers. There were therefore no true positives and false negatives for estimation of sensitivity, and this study was excluded
Healthcare 1999 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Heger 2008 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Hernandezguio 1965 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Herrera 2003 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Hidalgo 2004 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Hohenberger 2000 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Holzman 1997 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Hunerbein 1999 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Hunerbein 2001 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Ialongo 2010 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Ialongo 2015 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Ido 1982 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Ihse 1984 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Ishida 1983 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Ishida 1984 Wrong target condition
Ivanov 1989 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Jackowski 1997 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Jakobs 1999 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Jarnagin 2000 Wrong target condition
Jayakrishnan 2015 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Jerby 1998 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Jimenez 2000 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Jimenez 2000a No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
John 1999 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Juzkow 1996 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Kadar 1997 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Kanazawa 1983 No separate data available for pancreatic or periampullary cancer
Kaplan 1979 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Karachristos 2005 Intervention between index test and reference standard
Kellokumpu 1996 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Kelly 2009 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Khamdanov 1983 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Kiyonaga 1982 Wrong target condition
Klingler 2000 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Krahenbuhl 1997 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Krustev 1998 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Kubyshkin 2000 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Kuster 1967 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Kwon 2002 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Lavonius 2001 Includes participants who were considered to be unresectable by CT scan
Lightdale 1992 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Liu 2004 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Long 2005 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Luque‐de Leon 1998 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Luque‐de Leon 1999 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Macutkiewicz 2009 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Madsen 1994 No separate data available for pancreatic or periampullary cancer
Madsen 1994a No separate data available for pancreatic or periampullary cancer
Maire 2004 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Maithel 2008 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Meduri 1994 The proportion of participants who were considered to be resectable after CT scan is not known
Metcalfe 2003 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Meyer 1973 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Misra 2012 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Molnar 2010 The proportion of patients who were considered to be resectable after CT scan is not known
Morak 2009 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Morganti 2005 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Mortensen 1996 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Muniraj 2013 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Muntean 2009 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Munteanu 2010 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Murugiah 1993 The proportion of participants who were considered to be resectable after CT scan is not known
Nagy 1999 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Nieveen 1996 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Nieveen 1997 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Nieveen 1998 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Nieveen 1999 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Nieveen 2000 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Nieveen 2003 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Nieveen 2003a No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Occelli 1999 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Palanivelu 2001 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Parks 2000 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Pedrazzoli 1994 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Pelton 1998 Insufficient diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Pietrabissa 1996 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Pietrabissa 1996a No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Pietrabissa 1999 Includes participants who were considered to be unresectable by CT scan
Pisters 2001 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Potkonjak 1974 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Ramshaw 1999 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Ribero 1994 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Rodgers 2003 No separate data available for pancreatic or periampullary cancer
Rothlin 1996 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Rumstadt 1997 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Rumstadt 1997a No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Saeian 1999 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Sand 1996 No separate data available for pancreatic or periampullary cancer
Santoro 2012 No information on whether the distant metastases were confirmed histologically as metastases
Sato 1985 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Satoi 2011 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Schachter 1999 Wrong target condition
Schmidt 1997 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Schmied 2000 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Schmielau 1997 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Schneider 2003 The proportion of participants who were considered to be resectable after CT scan is not known
Schnelldorfer 2014 Not clear whether histopathological confirmation of metastasis was obtained
Schrenk 1994 Number of participants with pancreatic or periampullary cancer was not reported
Schrenk 1995 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Schwab 1996 Includes participants with unresectable cancers on CT scan
Sperlongano 2005 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Sperlongano 2006 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Tang 2001 No separate data available for pancreatic or periampullary cancer
Tapper 2011 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Taylor 2001 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Terrosu 2000 Number of participants with pancreatic or periampullary cancer was not reported
Thomson 2006 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Tilleman 2004 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Tilleman 2004a No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Toughrai 2013 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
van Delden 1996 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
van Dijkum 1997 The proportion of participants who were considered to be resectable after CT scan is not known
Velanovich 1998 No separate data available for pancreatic or periampullary cancer
Velanovich 2004 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Velasco 2000 The proportion of participants who were considered to be resectable after CT scan is not known
Vollmer 2002 Includes participants who were considered to be unresectable by CT scan
Warshaw 1990 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Warshaw 1990a Includes participants who were considered to be unresectable by CT scan
Watanabe 1993 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Weiner 1995 No separate data available for pancreatic or periampullary cancer
White 2001 Intervention between index test and reference standard
White 2004 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
White 2008 Wrong target condition
Wilson 2010 Not a diagnostic accuracy study
Yoshida 2002 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy
Zhao 2003 No diagnostic test accuracy data available for diagnostic laparoscopy

CT: computed tomography